Guess what monster fish this is

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Here are a couple pics of the Ptychocheilus oregonensis, northern pike minnow and worlds largest true minnow, formerly known as northern squawfish before the politically correct crowd sent in the word police, I catch a lot of these and in some places there is a bounty on them. I caught one day before yesterday that was about 14" long. that is an average size but they have been caught at over 60"s and I once caught one in Washington state that was almost 4 feet long.

I don't think it is a pikeminnow.

big_pic_northern_pikeminnow.jpg

pikemi1.jpg
 
My first guess is a Barbel (Barbus bardus) but I can't see any whiskers, so maybe a Vimba (Vimba vimba)
If those aren't right how about confirming if it is a cyprinid?

TN_barbus_barbus.jpg

vimba2.jpg

vim.jpg
 
Barbus graellsii?.... can we get more pictures. The Asian cyprinid group is a large group of fish, and many look alike when older. There are less appreciable differences among them than some other species
 
barbus andrewi looks similar, but from africa. i could name a dozen of similar species. probably all originated from one that have just established a subpopulation and considered as a geographical variation.
 
Pictures of this guy are hard to find, here is a drawing though. More detail then the picture.
drawing.jpg
. I will narrow it down even more. They are found in Iraq and Turkey.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com