Has fishkeeping ever ruined a relationship?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
No, he doesn't have time for ANYTHING except the fish, so it's not just me he doesn't have time for.. We used to go to my brothers and hang out, or we would all go to dinner, or find something to go do together.. He doesn't even want to go out of the house if it's not for fish.

And I have told him several times that if this isn't what he wants, then I will go. We aren't tied to anything together, so I can pick up and go at anytime and he can go about living his life.

Trust me, that has been talked about several times.

I have discussed that maybe he goes to the doctors, as he is to be taking meds for depression, so maybe getting those meds he needs will help. He thinks he doesn't need them, but there are things we all need that we think we don't.
 
I have discussed that maybe he goes to the doctors, as he is to be taking meds for depression, so maybe getting those meds he needs will help. He thinks he doesn't need them, but there are things we all need that we think we don't.

as do you. this is a problem that has become far too personal to be worth continuing on mfk.

your on your way to depression too if you try to hard to muscle this situation out. your being dragged from a rope on the back of a pickup at this point. the longer you hold onto it, the longer you'l burn. why hasn't he stopped the truck? why is he still driving away? why are you still holding the rope?

he's trying to keep his mind off of something. you even told him so. we are here to sympathize with you. but being biased on a forum where we all love fish, theres alot of grey opinion. examine yourself as well. how / why would he be locked in with his fish more than you? adapt and change are the only way out. and it will end with one. either way, your burning yourself in this situation the way you are.
 
as do you. this is a problem that has become far too personal to be worth continuing on mfk.

your on your way to depression too if you try to hard to muscle this situation out. your being dragged from a rope on the back of a pickup at this point. the longer you hold onto it, the longer you'l burn. why hasn't he stopped the truck? why is he still driving away? why are you still holding the rope?

he's trying to keep his mind off of something. you even told him so. we are here to sympathize with you. but being biased on a forum where we all love fish, theres alot of grey opinion. examine yourself as well. how / why would he be locked in with his fish more than you? adapt and change are the only way out. and it will end with one. either way, your burning yourself in this situation the way you are.

Note I said there are thing WE all need to fix... WE meaning me as well. I know there are things I need to work on, and I am working on them. But as I said before things don't happen overnight. Yes, adapt and change is the only way out.. but as the saying was said on here "you can't have your cake and eat it too..." Well, you can't eat a cake you don't have.

I am not saying that I want the the fish to be gone... I want the fish to be his hobby again, and not an obsession.

At what point does a hobby become an obsession? Many of you think it's deep appreciation for the hobby is what he's doing.. but what is he was gambling on horse races instead of buying fish... would you call it an obsession then? Just because it's in another form doesn't mean anything.

I don't believe in just giving up. Just throwing the towel in and being done.. It's like my viewpoint on marriage. I personally don't believe in Divorce UNLESS you have exhausted all of your options (counseling, separationg etc) and you still can not get along- unless kids are involved, then it's all about doing what's best for them. But anyways.. I also think that a bump in the road no matter how big shouldn't be given up on without reason and effort. Too many people just up and leave, and then they are back and forth constantly.. why not just deal with the hard times and make it work. Save yourself some time.

Yes, I am emotionally exhausted from trying to find out way to get my point across, but thinking about it.. maybe it's not me that needs to get the point across... maybe it's him. Maybe he needs to work on something that I don't know about.. That I can't fix.

Regardless of anything, the major bump with my issue is the fish obsession. I would feel better if he at least gave me the 2 hours after work to just relax on the couch with me, or watch tv.. I am not expecting him to be some super cuddly moochy kissy face guy. I just enjoy the presence of his company.

And I am sure than any one in a long term relationship would understand this. It's not about the content of the company, but the company itself.

But, in the even that someone can give me more ideas, I will listen to them all. Stop with the "then why are you with him.. there are other issues... blah blah.." because there aren't any on my end that I know of.
 
To reiterate.. your problem isn't the fish keeping... to put it bluntly.. if he wanted to spend that time with you.. he would.
 
To reiterate.. your problem isn't the fish keeping... to put it bluntly.. if he wanted to spend that time with you.. he would.

Wow.. maybe you just made it clear.

Thank you MFK thank you.
 
Don't post your problems on a public discussion forum and then be upset by the responses... There's a book out there you might want to check out:

hes-just-not-that-into-you-photo.jpg


Don't take that offensively either, it's not your fault. Sounds like you don't have a lot of experience dating people in your adulthood but let me put it bluntly: if a guy is crazy about you, he makes time for you. It just might not be what you want to hear, and sounds like there are multiple psychological issues going on as well.
 
Don't post your problems on a public discussion forum and then be upset by the responses... There's a book out there you might want to check out:

hes-just-not-that-into-you-photo.jpg


Don't take that offensively either, it's not your fault. Sounds like you don't have a lot of experience dating people in your adulthood but let me put it bluntly: if a guy is crazy about you, he makes time for you. It just might not be what you want to hear, and sounds like there are multiple psychological issues going on as well.

I have this book. If he wasn't into me, I wouldn't still be living here; as the house is his, not mine. He would do anything for me, he just doesn't show it the way that I need it.
 
Dude, I've stayed with girls I wasn't that in to, every guy has I think. Sometimes you just get comfortable... You're not thinking like a guy and that's why you're drawing conclusions that aren't necessarily correct. Guys are more than capable of staying with women for extended periods of time, especially if they're busy and it's convenient--doesn't mean they're that in to it. There's something to be said for codependence as well since he obviously has other psychological issues.

I don't mean to sound cold but if he was that in to you he wouldn't spend 4 hours a day like you described down in the fish room away from you. He makes time for the fish because he really likes fish... Not making time for you because... You fill in the blank.
 
Well, then I'll move out. That seems to be the easiest fix. Since we all know he's not into me.

Apparently men that aren't into women spend $3000+ dollars on an engagement ring, and propose too!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com