How to I.D. Black bar's at quarter size?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I'm still firm on my opinion that you have EBH's there. If you compare the bar on both the hooks you have you will notice that the bar on the smaller ones are about the same thickness as those on the larger ERH's.
attachment.php


Also the hooks on the smaller hooks seem more platnium than red to me so that's another reason why I believe they are EBH's. Mine were also quarter size when I got them a little over a month ago and they look just like the ones you have. I would expect growth around 1" per month or more depending on your water changes and feeding frequency.
 
:iagree:
 
pwmin;4486055; said:
based on this and another post it seems like TFD has both EBH and ERH. I got 6 from them and they all look like EBH's to me

What other post are you referring too?

RedDwarf;4486767; said:
I'm still firm on my opinion that you have EBH's there. If you compare the bar on both the hooks you have you will notice that the bar on the smaller ones are about the same thickness as those on the larger ERH's.
attachment.php


Also the hooks on the smaller hooks seem more platnium than red to me so that's another reason why I believe they are EBH's. Mine were also quarter size when I got them a little over a month ago and they look just like the ones you have. I would expect growth around 1" per month or more depending on your water changes and feeding frequency.

that would be cool if they are. I guess i should know in a month or so at 1" per month.

I notice when i first turn on the lights the bar is real pronounced and seems real wide.
 
There are two common kinds of Black Barred Silver Dollars, The thinbars and widebars. There is one more specie but it is the rarest of the trio.
 
pwmin;4489247; said:
there's a FS post (http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=356611) where he was looking for some EBH and said that a couple vendors had some ERH's; I talked to him in a PM and asked who and he said TFD.


Here's a new one where bomber got some ERH ("half dollar" size) from TFD: http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=359248

mine are definitely EBH's

Ahh OK.

Yea I am pretty sure that mine are too. The bars are getting bigger now that they have settled in. They also already look bigger after a week.
 
keepinfish;4489272; said:
Ahh OK.

Yea I am pretty sure that mine are too. The bars are getting bigger now that they have settled in. They also already look bigger after a week.
the suspect ones look like EBH's to me
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com