How would You Cook This?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I'll eat venison if there's nothing else, but if I have a choice of steaks such as sirloin, fillet, ostrich etc; venison is last on my list.

As others have said, it does have a gamey taste; which tends to leave an aftertaste. Still very nutritious, but perhaps more of an acquired taste.

Don't let us put you off though, you'll probably really enjoy it!
 
Absolutely 2 minutes each side, I tend to go 3 and 1 but doesn't matter. I personally very much dislike venison, I find it too gamey and I definitely do not enjoy the aftertaste. That being said, honey garlic venison strips are perhaps some of the best wild game I have eaten, second only to the spicy pepperets. When I ate them they were cut into strips and cooked in the honey garlic sauce, great for stiryfry or with sides of whatever, as much as I dislike venison I still find myself thinking about those honey garlic strips (and I am a hot sauce guy, give me any suicide wings and I haven't eaten chocolate or candy in over 5 years because it turns me right off).

Matt when you get back home invest in a smoker. Changed my life man, wait for them to go on sale at TSC, the best way to eat period!
What is TSC ? Thanks
 
Tractor Supplies Company.......right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: HumanBean
What is TSC ? Thanks

Hardware store in Canada. Better than home hardware and Rona IMO, less selection that Home Depot but will carry the specialty stuff, and they actually have good sales (I got $100 off my smoker). Lowes is probably the best hardware store overall at least in my area, Home Depot is hit or miss, their lumber sucks, don't have the specialty stuff that this and other hobbies tend to demand (ie. Lowes has 1.5" pvc and home depot caps at 1"). TSC definitely a smaller store with a homehardware type of feel, but I do like it a lot, people tend to be very helpful and carries a lot of outdoor stuff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HumanBean
Hardware store in Canada. Better than home hardware and Rona IMO, less selection that Home Depot but will carry the specialty stuff, and they actually have good sales (I got $100 off my smoker). Lowes is probably the best hardware store overall at least in my area, Home Depot is hit or miss, their lumber sucks, don't have the specialty stuff that this and other hobbies tend to demand (ie. Lowes has 1.5" pvc and home depot caps at 1"). TSC definitely a smaller store with a homehardware type of feel, but I do like it a lot, people tend to be very helpful and carries a lot of outdoor stuff.
Oh yea tractor supply chain. Yup that's correct.

I agree Lowes by far the best in Halton area
 
I love any cut of steak marinated overnight in a light spring/summer flavor like Hawaiian or Polynesian marinade, then cooked at max. heat for about 3.5-4 minutes each side in a frying pan w/ lots of melted butter/robust Italian dressing mix, fresh minced garlic, salt, pepper, onion powder, garlic powder, and maybe some A-1 sauce. Let the meat rest for a good 5 minutes before cutting into it.

I have a friend who does venison chili and it's amazing.

I have done ground venison burgers and they are amazing.

I also use the tougher parts of the deer as "chopped sirloin" and dice them for a stir-fry w/ veggies.

You can't go wrong by throwing venison in a crockpot and cooking it on low for 6-10 hours.

...or you can do the same in a frying pan on the lowest setting as long as the venison is completely submerged in liquid (NOT the marinade you used to flavor it, it absorbs the gamey flavor). Do NOT use a lid, and if you need a splatter guard, it's too hot.

you can country-fry it in oil and douse it with gravy.

you can cover it with foil in a pan or cookie sheet and bake it (teriyaki style is my favorite) 450F, 4-6 minutes PER HALF- INCH of thickness of steak (example 1.5 inches = 12 - 15 minutes. Flip halfway through.

You can do it on the broiler rack if you're REALLY good.....or you can ruin it on the broiler rack if you're not REALLY good.

No one's hatin' if you throw it on the grill either, but it just doesn't stay as tender and juicy as a frying pan w/ liquid.

Or you can dehydrate it and make jerky....

But if it's not going into the pan, IMO, throwing it in a smoker for a good 8-12 hours or so is my other favorite way to do it....but do yourself a favor....don't fire up the smoker JUST for a steak or 2 - go hit the store, grab a rack of ribs, some fresh fish fillets, Italian sausage, a whole chicken, burgers or w/e you prefer, and fill that entire smoker to the brim. Smoked meat has a much longer shelf life than cooked by other methods and can be cooled in the open and frozen for later use. Don't need to cook it again, just defrost and eat it if you like.

P.S. the fish fillets generally only take 4 hours, larger ones in the 2-4 lb range can take 6-8, but the fish will almost ALWAYS be done before the beef and pork because of the thickness of the cuts.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AlG and davenmandy
Teriyaki marinade is the best deer I've had... That's basically the most popular beef style here as well. Korean bulgogi is hard to beat too but not as common. Really tenderizes the meat if you go overnight. Especially if it didn't just "fall over"at the butchers.
 
Just butter and pepper man, I am also a student but being an avid hunter makes my freezer full of venison. Like others have said, you dont need to season it at all but you have to like the taste of it to enjoy it, very gamey.
 
Korean bulgogi is hard to beat
Those Korean pear based marinade/sauce are fantastic. I wonder how they would taste applied to venison. I need to start hunting again.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com