Hybrid Catfish Discussion thread.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
N: It really depends on what type of DNA analysis they perform. I will have to look up my emails from Dr. Lundberg and see what he said about it. I am not that big into DNA myself, but started doing some research on it when I thought I was going to try to make hybrids myself. I actually have a guide that I put together to try this myself. I did so much research on the subject and was able to find the sources of the hybrids themselves and get some good info from them as well. :) Luckily I have all this information saved for when I am better able to test this stuff out. lol, I don't know why but I really wanted to try a Jau x LSN.
TBTB: You appear to belong in the SA jungle or in SE Asia where they do all this :) :) :)

N: I can say with certainty that my MRTC was L. Marmoratus. I have a Marmoratus skeleton that I compared to the hybrid skeleton. Seems to me a great match when taking into account the characteristics of the RTC in it also.
TBTB: I thought you said you weren't sure - marmoratus vs pictus? Now you are sure of marmoratus, right?

N: ... I was also told that fasciatum is the most common TSN species used for this...
TBTB: 1. Do you think fasciatum is used for the TSN x blochii or for any hybrid involving a TSN?
TBTB: 2. Do you have a guess at which species was the mother and the father for any hybrids?

N: I can say from my disection of this specimen that this fish had a conflict of skeletal and muscular anatomy. When hybridized catfish(possibly all fish) seem to have a special ability to hybridize on a higher level than other vertebrates. This is something that Dr. Lundberg and I were discussing. Usually hybridization is only possible within a genus according text books. Catfish have definitely proven that hybrids can go out farther than this. Either it is false that hybrids only occur within a genus, or all catfish species are more closely related than previously considered. It would seem strange that nearly all catfish are capable of hybridization so they should all be in the same genera. Whose ever heard of a genus of vertebrates containing over 3000 species?
TBTB: That's a shocking thought, albeit one must note it is prematurely too sweeping and general, but yes, some cats even from different families have been hybridized, like Doradids and Pims, Pangasiidae and Pims. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle, as usual.

N: It's also of note that when I got this fish it was 14" and only grew 2" in the year I owned it before it died during a power outage.
TBTB: Which fish? Leiarius x RTC or the TSN x blochii?
N: TSN x Blochii
TBTB: As you said, it didn't eat well. I'd not expect it to stop growing or slow so much, unless it was one of those zombie hybrids, as you mentioned, which do not survive to adultood/not viable.
 
TBTB: You appear to belong in the SA jungle or in SE Asia where they do all this :) :) :).

N: haha I wish. My favorite fish and also lots of cute girls! ;)

TBTB: I thought you said you weren't sure - marmoratus vs pictus? Now you are sure of marmoratus, right?
N: The only problem I have is that I don't have a pictus skeleton for proper comparison. Comparing the marmoratus skeleton it really is striking how much similar the hybrid is to it. IMO I would definitely go with marmoratus. When I relook at the skeletons it's just way too similar. Way more marble in it than RTC from the looks of it. I will have to get some good pics or do a vid explaining the comparison. Unfortunately the skeleton of the hybrid is damaged where chlorine was poured into my pond to kill it. chlorine damages the calcium bonds causing the bones to fall apart over time. I'm very carefully trying to preserve it.


TBTB: 1. Do you think fasciatum is used for the TSN x blochii or for any hybrid involving a TSN?
TBTB: 2. Do you have a guess at which species was the mother and the father for any hybrids?
N: 1. I would say it is more than likely. My previous statement along with comparison of the skeletons suggests so. There have also been pseudoplatystoma x pseudoplatystoma hybrids.
2. According to the hybrid research I have done usually the larger species is the mother, and smaller one is the father. This I believe has more to do with egg production. Females can be used over and over again to produce hybrids, but the males have to be dissected for their testes. They can use ultrasound to determine sex then dose specific amounts of hormones to induce egg and sperm productions then again for the artificial spawning.


TBTB: That's a shocking thought, albeit one must note it is prematurely too sweeping and general, but yes, some cats even from different families have been hybridized, like Doradids and Pims, Pangasiidae and Pims. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle, as usual.
N: This is why I was working so hard to get lots of adult catfish raised. My plan when I finished the 4000 gal aquarium was going to be building 6 500 gal tanks that would be used to raise multiple adults of various large species from around the world, then get an ultrasound so that I could sex the fish and seperate them by sex. It would have been pretty small scale for what you would actually hope for, but I am just too curious to leave it up to people looking to make a profit. I was going to sample the offspring every week, then every month, and then yearly for disection and to send to Dr. Lundbergs team for analysis. This way I could control the parameters of what was going on. I could have also sold enough of them to keep going on the research as well. Hopefully I can try to kick this off again in the future. :( I was even making a list of species I wanted to test this on. I wanted to see if it is just that pimelodid catfish are good for this or if you could do this with other families of catfish. As in not have a pimlodid as one of the parent species. Maybe try like a goonch x bullhead or something like that. I felt that both bullheads and goonch exist in cool mountain streams so there shouldn't be much in the way of metabolic issues. You get the point lol.


TBTB: As you said, it didn't eat well. I'd not expect it to stop growing or slow so much, unless it was one of those zombie hybrids, as you mentioned, which do not survive to adultood/not viable.[/QUOTE]

N: it's not as if I thought it's appetite was reduced at all just seemed as if this fish ate very little because it didn't need more. Very interesting seeing the skeletal characteristics of this one lol.
 

Yes I have seen these before sold as Tsn x niger. Would love to get my hands on that big one if heaven forbid it dies one day. i take it that it is in asia. i had some pics of some very interesting catfish hybrids in aasia. Would be nice if some of the asian members could post up some pics of the add hybrids they have seen. i still don't have a niger catfish skeleton. i have a need to collect more specimens for comparison. Dr. lundberg has made his collection available to me for study whenever I like, but it's over a thousand miles away from me lol. I was planning a trip to go and photograph them all, but couldn't come up with the money for the trip plus time off work.
 
If only I had known, I'd provide you with lots of skeletons. I've had a disaster similar to yours in magnitude when I lost like a hundred adult and sub-adult cats and Co during a botched move from upstate NY to SW FL. One was a 3' niger.
 
Glad to see your back!!! Your name look's good in red also...
I think the catfish section just got better. lol. I can't wait to see some of the many upcoming thread's of yours, that are sure to come.
 
Glad to see your back!!! Your name look's good in red also...
I think the catfish section just got better. lol. I can't wait to see some of the many upcoming thread's of yours, that are sure to come.

Thanks. It's nice to see some of my old favorite members still around also. Also sad to see that some have died or left MFK all together. Hopefully with the help of those following the catfish section we can revamp this section and give it new life!!! Nice to see some discussion, but nothing like what it use to be. I'd like to see people getting back to trying to help each other and not bashing each other. This isn't the forum section of some other catfish sites lol. I still believe that you can be helpful without scaring people away where they will likely do something we don't wish to happen. People get desperate and don't always know what they are getting in to. Fish stores don't help with false information so when they come on here not knowing and get attack by members that know more it's frustrating to me. I can remember being that gullible guy in the fish store that had to have the RTC that's label said it would only get to 12", only to find out a few weeks later it could grow to 4'!!!! lol. Good news is tonight I am getting another fish tank for free!!!! That will bring me up to 2 fish tanks!!!. I might actually Start gathering some fish tanks and supplies for the future and store them for when I have my own place lol.
 
IMG-20110813-00013.jpg

Here's a peak of the hybrid's neurocranium!!!

IMG-20110813-00013.jpg
 
IMG-20110911-00113.jpg

How about three hybrid neurocraniums in a row? Top RTC x TSN, middle Marble x TSN, bottom TSN x blochii

IMG-20110911-00113.jpg
 
this thread is one of the best ones I've seen in a while i'd love to see some bagarius or brachyplatystoma crosses as of now i'm not aware of any specimens out there hopefully you might know of any out there :)


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com