ID This Sunfish!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

sandtiger

Captain Planet
MFK Member
Feb 14, 2005
3,563
4
0
41
NY
Can anyone tell me what species this is?

DSCN6162-1.jpg


You're probably wondering why the picture is B&W. That is because it has come to my attention that too many people are relying on color alone in order to ID a fish. As all of you should know fish change color, they fade in and out, loose their color when they're dead and can exhibit a great deal of diversity in colors between populations. I'm not giving you any hints, there are only 32 species of sunfishes and quite a few that this one quite obviously is not. In addition to telling me what species this is I would also like you to tell me how you got to the conclusion that it is what it is. If you don't have a field guide there is a key stickied to the top of this forum specifically for IDing Centrarchids. Good luck!

P.S. I know there are some members who might recognize this individual fish or the species immediately, I would appreciate it if we let the more inexperienced members handle this one.
 
apharing;2679497; said:
is that a pumpkinseed?
No, its ear look wrong for a pumpkinseed but i know the answer so ill keep my mouth shut.
 
apharing;2679497; said:
is that a pumpkinseed?

Like I said, you have to say why you think it is what it is. Otherwise people might just ramble off all 32 species and are bound to get it.
 
sorry, i thought it was a pumpkinseed because of the pattern on its face. i catch them all the time. i never eat the pumpkinseeds though, theyre too pretty lol
 
Is it a orangespotted sunfish?
 
apharing;2679561; said:
sorry, i thought it was a pumpkinseed because of the pattern on its face. i catch them all the time. i never eat the pumpkinseeds though, theyre too pretty lol

There are many sunfishes with that pattern on their face, pumpkinseeds included. However I am not going to confirm or deny that it is a pumpkinseed at this time.
 
I think what sandtiger is trying to get at here is the importance of making statements like this:

I believe it's an ornagespotted sunfish because it has this color around it's opercle,
this body shape as well as this pattern on it's blah blah blah

edit...oops sorry no color but you get the point.
 
longear sunfish? it fits the profile and the opercle is highlighted
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com