Is a 240 too small for a Jardini?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Status
Not open for further replies.
Darth Scohin;4310700; said:
My Afro seems to be fine tuned at turning not as much as a silver but definately more than a Jar or Asian So I'd say it'd be fine.....

Again mate don't really recommend the Jar it could end badly....

I'm only (sorta) familiar with silvers, so give me the low-down on Jardini (& other aros) levels of aggression. This is the stuff I want to find out about now, not after I've lost several fish. "Pretend" I'm stupid- if I knew everything I would not be on this site.
 
Darth Scohin;4310700; said:
My Afro seems to be fine tuned at turning not as much as a silver but definately more than a Jar or Asian So I'd say it'd be fine.....

Again mate don't really recommend the Jar it could end badly....
Oh, I didn't know that, I wasn't speaking from any personal experience, I just assumed that due to their body shape, they'd have a harder time turning around. But yeah, I agree, a jar would be way too risky.
 
Is the Silver probably my best choice?
 
lujor;4310749; said:
Is the Silver probably my best choice?
Yeah, I'd definitely either go with a silver or a black (preferably a black, but they are a lot more rare than silvers, and cost about three times as much).
 
lujor;4310713; said:
I'm only (sorta) familiar with silvers, so give me the low-down on Jardini (& other aros) levels of aggression. This is the stuff I want to find out about now, not after I've lost several fish. "Pretend" I'm stupid- if I knew everything I would not be on this site.
The link that was posted in post #8 should give you most of the info you need on the different species of aros. But here are some of my opinions on the pros and cons of each species:

Silver aro
Pros: large size- could be seen as a pro or a con, very graceful movement, very hardy ime, very flexible- don't require an extremely wide tank, they are usually tolerant of most tankmates that will not easily fit into their mouth (and many people have had great success keeping them with much smaller tankmates, like angels, small tetras, etc., the only fish they are almost always intolerant of are other arowanas that have a similar body shape

Cons: DE (or drop eye) is basically inevitable in most specimens kept in aquariums, as with all other aro species they are very jumpy and are capable of jumping out of a tank, even if it has a lid that is weighed down, as stated previously, they will not usually tolerate other silver or black aros in the same tank unless they are kept in a group of 5 or more individuals

Black aro
Pros:basically the same as the silver aros, with a few additions: they are more colorful until they get to about 4 years+, DE is very uncommon in this species, and they seem to be more tolerant of other aros in the same tank

Cons: they are rare and expensive (the cheapest I have heard of was $150 for a 4-5 incher).

Jardini/leichardti arowanas
Pros: much smaller than the SA aros, as far as I know they aren't nearly as prone to DE

Cons: become aggressive after 8" and usually will kill any tankmates they are put with (though there have been a few exceptions), they're much less colorful than the SA aros, and not nearly as graceful.
 
drgnfrc13;4312006; said:
Cons: become aggressive after 8" and usually will kill any tankmates they are put with (though there have been a few exceptions), they're much less colorful than the SA aros, and not nearly as graceful.

It's your own opinion and I respect it, but I was always told that Jardinis had better color variations than the Silver. Which is why Jardini's usually cost more than silvers. Last I checked, silvers only come in...silver. Unless you manage to get your hands on a platinum silver... but even then there's also the platinum Jardini. Jardini's have gold, red brown, dark green and even black. The black arowana has only 2 colors. They're partially black when juvenile and blue as adults.
 
Your tank would have the minimum width for a jardini. Everybody from personal experience seem fine wit a 24" silver in a 24" tank. Yet are there any people with a 30"+ silver in a 24" tank that are fine with it? I have 2 silvers nearing 30", and 24" would be way too narrow a tank to keep them in. Need to be thinking 8' long and 3' wide as a minimum.

BTW the tank depth recommend has very little to do with "room to turn around".
 
HighBackRTG;4312133; said:
It's your own opinion and I respect it, but I was always told that Jardinis had better color variations than the Silver. Which is why Jardini's usually cost more than silvers. Last I checked, silvers only come in...silver. Unless you manage to get your hands on a platinum silver... but even then there's also the platinum Jardini. Jardini's have gold, red brown, dark green and even black. The black arowana has only 2 colors. They're partially black when juvenile and blue as adults.

Yeah right, post some pics of all these adult variations of jardini you claim.
 
Bderick67;4312392; said:
Your tank would have the minimum width for a jardini. Everybody from personal experience seem fine wit a 24" silver in a 24" tank. Yet are there any people with a 30"+ silver in a 24" tank that are fine with it? I have 2 silvers nearing 30", and 24" would be way too narrow a tank to keep them in. Need to be thinking 8' long and 3' wide as a minimum.

BTW the tank depth recommend has very little to do with "room to turn around".
Why else would depth even matter? And I've seen members here who have (or have had) large aros recommend the 6x2 footprint multiple times (you're not the only member here who owns large arows ;)).
 
HighBackRTG;4312133; said:
It's your own opinion and I respect it, but I was always told that Jardinis had better color variations than the Silver. Which is why Jardini's usually cost more than silvers. Last I checked, silvers only come in...silver. Unless you manage to get your hands on a platinum silver... but even then there's also the platinum Jardini. Jardini's have gold, red brown, dark green and even black. The black arowana has only 2 colors. They're partially black when juvenile and blue as adults.
Uh, jars come in four colors: dark brown, regular brown, light brown, or one of those shades with a small amount of red petterning. Silvers have highly varying colors (that is until they get to around 30"+). My silver is currently at about 24" and it has many different shades of green, blue, turquoise, and red (as well as silver, but that one's obvious). The only problem with silver aros' coloration is that it can be difficult to get pics of (most of the time, my pics either show the red or the green/blue, but rarely both).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MonsterFishKeepers.com