is it okay to keep oscars with Jar?

[busterbrown]

they should be fine, i have my jar with a gatf, discus and a dat. they all do fine

 

[kevinngo94]

i had two Oscars with a jar,
the jar killed both of them,

 

[C.A.S.A.]

they should be fine, i have my jar with a gatf, discus and a dat. they all do fine

Most likely the reason your comm. works is because there was so many fish and the aggression is spread out not to just one fish

 

[Mr.Nooby]

alright then. i might have to get a bottom dweller fish then so the jar wont bother it much. maybe a bichir.

 

[903]

I would like to take back my comment I made earlier in this thread. I witnessed my friend's jar attacking his 3 oscars last night. His Jar was around 7 inches and his oscars were around 4 1/2 - 5. His fishes were feed daily also. Just wanted to let you know.

 

[sbuse]

alright then. i might have to get a bottom dweller fish then so the jar wont bother it much. maybe a bichir.

my jar was and have been fine with bichirs, catfish, stingrays, pleco and a few more...i am tring them with dats now, they are still young so it is not a true test yet...so far they are only agressive tward other aros...

 

[Mr.Nooby]

I would like to take back my comment I made earlier in this thread. I witnessed my friend's jar attacking his 3 oscars last night. His Jar was around 7 inches and his oscars were around 4 1/2 - 5. His fishes were feed daily also. Just wanted to let you know.

aite thanks for your update. i might get a different fish to be with my jar. if not then maybe i will just try to keep it alone and maybe introduce it to another jar as it gets older.

 

[Mr.Nooby]

my jar was and have been fine with bichirs, catfish, stingrays, pleco and a few more...i am tring them with dats now, they are still young so it is not a true test yet...so far they are only agressive tward other aros...

i was thinking about that too. those dats are pretty nice fish.

 

[sbuse]

i was thinking about that too. those dats are pretty nice fish.

if you get dats(i think they still have some at forest lake though i dented their stock... i took several) do alot of plants and i just added a rock plie to the dat tank and they are in it more then anything else...they are more active and showing good colors with the rock addition...

 

[C.A.S.A.]

Good luck with whatever tankmates you choose!