Keyholes

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I kept Keyholes a few years back. Don't underestimate them.

I had read they were shy and peaceful, a great community fish.

So into my community tank they went.

They ate all of the Cardinal & Glowlight tetras in fairly short order.

The 4 keyholes hunted them like wolves once the light were out. They'd nip of the fins or the eyes, and then eventually eat the remains.

Anyhow, I had 1 male & 3 females in that batch. The male got closer to 6" than to 4", but the females stayed in that 3.5" to 4" range.

I don't think they should be kept with Convicts or JD's, but they did fine for me with Severums, Festivums, Angels, and a couple species of Geos (Steindachneri & RH Tapajos). They can also be kept with other dwarf cichlids.

But beware the noodle shaped tetra - they will be lunch!
So far they fit right in they are literally the smallest fish in my tank but all 5 stick together and no one has bothered them. And they have already eaten flakes, pellets, and bloodworms. I'm looking forward to seeing them get bigger they already have beautiful markings. How did you sex them ?
 
Nice! I also joined the keyhole club last week. I got two to go in a planted a tank with some festivums. Such outgoing little guys at 1". I had looked at them before, but the lfs always had 4" adults for like $30, but they finally got some juvies in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alexxxxsv14
Nice! I also joined the keyhole club last week. I got two to go in a planted a tank with some festivums. Such outgoing little guys at 1". I had looked at them before, but the lfs always had 4" adults for like $30, but they finally got some juvies in.
Right on bro! Yah I've always wanted some but my tanks were always pretty aggressive. Right now I have a SA community tank with more placid cichlids so i figured they fit in. My lfs never carried them and especially when I wanted them so I went to a shop that had them and had to pick up group of 5, for 4$ each couldn't resist. They are fun to watch and I love the marking on mine can't wait for them to get bigger !
 
^^ That's exactly why I'm only keeping one for the time being. If he can eat the adult angels and torpedo sausage SAEs, he's in with, then I'll re-think.
 
^^ That's exactly why I'm only keeping one for the time being. If he can eat the adult angels and torpedo sausage SAEs, he's in with, then I'll re-think.
Yours ate an angel fish ? Dang how big is your keyhole
 
We have 4 keyholes in our 265 gallon South American community tank. They are in there with 6 Geophagus Red Head Tapajos, 13 tiger striped silver dollars, a Coryphaenoides chocolate cichlid, a pink tail Chalceus, and two plecos (bristlenose and rubber lip). They were very shy at the very beginning, but now they are at the top of the tank during feeding time. A very underrated cichlid. They are fun to watch, especially when they gill flare at each other. They almost "kiss" each other rather than fight, too. They have plenty of hiding places in our tank to help them feel comfortable and can get away from the commotion the Tapajos can create.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alexxxxsv14
I wasn't able to sex mine until they spawned, and then once the breeding tubes were down it was easy (typical too: males, small pointy. Females, large & blunt).
Later, as they matured beyond just being able to spawn the Male got noticeably bigger, thicker, and had a steeper forehead. I wouldn't go so far as to call it a nuchal hump, but it was different when seen next to the females.

Also, that old adage about males getting longer pointier dorsal and anal fins? That was true - but for the longest time both sexes had trailers that extended to the back edge of the caudal fin, or close to it. However, as the male matured his trailers got even longer.
They extended past the caudal fin and this part is going to be hard to describe but the trailers on the dorsal fin kind of curled down a bit, and then extended past the caudal fin, and the anal fin trailer kind of curled up and then extended past the caudal fin...

It was almost as if the trailers grew closer together and THEN started shooting straight out past the caudal fin on my old male.

Again, hard to describe but easy to notice when you see it. I'll see if I can find an old photo (it's on an older computer that may or may not work)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alexxxxsv14
We have 4 keyholes in our 265 gallon South American community tank. They are in there with 6 Geophagus Red Head Tapajos, 13 tiger striped silver dollars, a Coryphaenoides chocolate cichlid, a pink tail Chalceus, and two plecos (bristlenose and rubber lip). They were very shy at the very beginning, but now they are at the top of the tank during feeding time. A very underrated cichlid. They are fun to watch, especially when they gill flare at each other. They almost "kiss" each other rather than fight, too. They have plenty of hiding places in our tank to help them feel comfortable and can get away from the commotion the Tapajos can create.
I agree they are great fish, just a few days and I already love them. They are so tiny still so they eat off of what my messy Severums spit out. I make sure to feed some flakes though so they get a good meal, and surprisingly they do go up to the top to get a pellet and then when one of them has the pellet all 4 others race behind him trying to steal his pellet it's quite amusing to watch. I definitely gnna keep them and start thinning out my stock, something about them in a group looks nice to the eye and they don't grow so big which is cool. Definitely underrated
 
I wasn't able to sex mine until they spawned, and then once the breeding tubes were down it was easy (typical too: males, small pointy. Females, large & blunt).
Later, as they matured beyond just being able to spawn the Male got noticeably bigger, thicker, and had a steeper forehead. I wouldn't go so far as to call it a nuchal hump, but it was different when seen next to the females.

Also, that old adage about males getting longer pointier dorsal and anal fins? That was true - but for the longest time both sexes had trailers that extended to the back edge of the caudal fin, or close to it. However, as the male matured his trailers got even longer.
They extended past the caudal fin and this part is going to be hard to describe but the trailers on the dorsal fin kind of curled down a bit, and then extended past the caudal fin, and the anal fin trailer kind of curled up and then extended past the caudal fin...

It was almost as if the trailers grew closer together and THEN started shooting straight out past the caudal fin on my old male.

Again, hard to describe but easy to notice when you see it. I'll see if I can find an old photo (it's on an older computer that may or may not work)
Thanks for taking the time to describe it, I actually know exactly what your talking about. I saw a lot of keyhole videos on YouTube lol and both male and female look very similar but the male looks more bulky and filled in. They have beautiful marking and the trailers do curve at the ends. Idk if yours has it but some of mine have a little bit of white on the rim of the upper area of the tail. On YouTube some had them and others didn't maybe it's just the line breeding of the fish or idk but it is something that I noticed even at the lfs bc I was making sure it wasn't bc they were sick or something but I seen it on some on YouTube and it looks real nice.
 
The sajica could prove problematic but the South American fish should be fine.

When people talk about cichlids being peaceful, it's usually in relation to other cichlids. Peaceful does not always mean tetra safe. Most New World cichlids will eat smaller fish given the opportunity; it's in their nature. Discus, angels, keyholes, etc. will often hunt and eat small tetras given the opportunity. In terms of aggression keyholes are one of the most timid SA cichlids you can get, but again that's all relative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alexxxxsv14
MonsterFishKeepers.com