my crazy theory

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
There have been experiments with this and id does have an effect on growth. Particularly with plants, because they are easier to experiment with. Increased carbon dioxide does increase plant growth.
But it is not just a matter of available gas.
Take a dragonfly. A balanced design based on flight. A power to weight ratio. A power to lift ratio.
They do not have lungs. They absorb O2 in a chamber of small tubes in their abdomen.
Growing biger means more tissue to fuel, means more tubes to breath, means more weight, more power to lift it, more muscle for power, more tubes to fuel the muscle etc. There is a limit. And end to cost benefit.
The idea of big things with more Oxygen is basically this. The cost benefit ratio changes.
In a heavy oxygen environment a dragonfly can adapt it's genetics to grow larger and more powerful while using less tubes to breath, because the air fuel mixture is more potent. They can fuel more muscle with less tubes. So more of the body is dedicated to lift, and a smaller percentage to fuel.
The power to weight ratio changes. More power, more lift, with less to lift. So there is excess power to lift an increased body size.
So they could grow to a few feet long and fly at around 100mph.
But if you take a modern dragonfly who's genetics are designed for a low oxygen environment and must be small, light and fuel efficient...It will grow better with more oxygen. To a limit. To the maximum size programed by it's genetics.
Like fish in our tanks. Limit resources and you stunt growth. It will not reach the full potential allowed by it's design.
With unlimited resources it will reach it's maximum potential easier.
But only to the maximum limit of it's genetic potential.
You might grow the biggest guppy we have ever seen.
But you can't change him into a Great White shark.
Because he is only, and always will be a guppy.
He can only breath so much and eat so much and grow so much.
But if you breed generations for a million years, maybe his children would learn to use the increased resources to grow larger and remain efficient.
 
here's something interesting i learned...

as we all know, colder water holds more O2. Arctic and antarctic waters are among the richest, both in oxygen and nutrients/food. Scientists have found species in arctic waters that also occur in other places (they used the icefish as example) that are almost 50% larger in the arctic. They also discovered the colossal squid (largest cephalopod) in the arctc. So, it's a good theory :)
 
Years ago, a buddy and myself bought Arowanas from the same batch. They were 4 inchers, looked almost identical. His was slightly larger...

We worked on the same Shrimp boat, and brought the prawns we fed them home from work.
Hikari food sticks and crickets were also fed...

Basically the only difference was the filtration...He used a canister and powerheads and I used a wet/dry.
My water was always clear and I did weekly 30% W/C

After a year or so My Arowana was noticably thicker and had more shine...

I would say based on my experience
water quality/oxygen content will allow your fish to reach their genetic potential faster...
 
Sounds to me like more O2 may promote fish growth in a home aquarium to me
i wish i could find something online about this but i really cant find anything relevant.
need more information though
 
r3d;1879358; said:
Sounds to me like more O2 may promote fish growth in a home aquarium to me
i wish i could find something online about this but i really cant find anything relevant.
need more information though

reverse feedback loops.. as in it's not the decrease of O2 that makes you breathe faster is the increased presense of CO2
 
colder water holds more oxygen... look how many big fish are cold water and how many big fish are warm water.... cold water wins.

and the dinosaurs evolved to be that big over millions of years... how long have humans been around? the average size of a human is gettin bigger with each generation. we'll be 10ft tall in about 500 years.
 
nativelover;1879557; said:
the average size of a human is gettin bigger with each generation. we'll be 10ft tall in about 500 years.


that's not true.. there's no drive to be taller anymore.. predators aren't picking off the shorts ones.. people are really F'ing with natural selection these days by having no decernable pattern in who mates with whom...
 
ok show me an ENTIRE population of people mating with people witht he exact same traits....

e.g and entire country mating with people with GIANT noses
 
Anyone else having any thoughts?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com