No one is buying this lonely guy

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Thanks for the articles, RD.

It confirms my fears and that Portland location reference makes me wary.

What do you think one should take away from this info?

I suppose a local club breeder might be a good way to source as in theory, those fish aren't being exposed to fish and water from various farms mixed together in one or several wholesale locations.

Im guessing my theory on trying to get the fish as directly as possible has merit as you skip more chances for additional exposure.

Divers den, again has me sold because of their quarantine procedure. The only other place I know of that does a quarantine is Cory's Aquarium Coop and he uses the med trio which these articles argue is bad bc of the prophylactic use of antibiotics as part of the trio.


This part of DDs procedure is one thing I like bc I read someone similar is done with as part of the public Aquarium procedure:

Disease Prevention
During the quarantine period, all new fish are treated with copper sulfate and a 37% formaldehyde solution to combat Ichthyophthirius multifiliis, ichthyobodosis, chilodonellosis and trichodinosis. Upon introduction to the quarantine system, we take an additional preventive approach to reduce stress by also using aquarium salt. Maintaining the salt level in our systems at 1.6ppt helps reduce stress by aiding fish gill function and ensures new arrivals do not experience "osmotic shock," a phenomenon where important electrolytes are lost through the gills and the fish's ability to take in oxygen and release carbon dioxide is impaired.


Of course, a long quarantine at home (at least a month, but I've heard of people do as long as 6 months). I've come to believe in prophylactic deworming with general cure and two rounds of levamisole (2-3 weeks apart). I figure those often don't show symptoms, though maybe you'd see symptoms in a 6 months quarantine, and I'd expect wild fish especially would have ample opportunity to be exposed to such parasites.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RD.
I don’t know if the debate is over but I would bet anything that it’s an altifrons. The very small eye spot and the tail fin pattern are the signs for me. I have 3 this size currently. They get a good bit larger than RHTs so if size is an issue that’s something else to consider.
 
Thanks Seth. No, still not over. I have been avoiding the shop this week or else I might get him. I am just still trying to talk myself out of it and it would be nice to be more informed what he/she is.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Matteus
Thanks Seth. No, still not over. I have been avoiding the shop this week or else I might get him. I am just still trying to talk myself out of it and it would be nice to be more informed what he/she is.
I would wager money it’s an altifrons and they reach 12 inches at times if that makes him less desireable for you. And their behavior is much better in groups so it takes a pretty big tank to keep multiples comfortably. Geos are super cool though and I would have a very hard time not rescuing the little one myself, so I understand your struggle!
 
Well, I lasted all week without visiting the shop so the desire is cooling down and I think if he's Geophagus altifrons, as beautiful as he's going to grow up, it's not going to go well either for him or my current fish if I add him to the pond...saying this with a really sad face :redface: He's not the first fish I've been drooling over so I hope it will pass...But if I setup another large tank or pond, Geophagus will be first on my list for sure. I really like these fish.

Thanks everyone for your input.

P.S. If he's still in the shop next time I walk in, I'll try taking a video rather than a picture.
 
  • Like
Reactions: islandguy11
For the reasons already stated by Seth, if G. altifrons I would most definitely pass. I have personally seen male adults reach 12", and I don't see this as a good fit for your tank, Cory. Maybe let the owner know what he has, and their potential max size.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Coryloach
While generally speaking I would agree, I once had a single RH Tapajos in with a group of clown loaches, and he picked on the smallest (male) clown loach in the group. Nothing violent, but he always directed his angst towards that loach as it was the only fish in the tank that he could dominate. About 18 months in I removed the geo due to this behaviour.

I thought I was the only one that had a freak Geo lol. I started out with a group of three Red Tapajos all about 4-5" in my 120g bichir tank and had one of them turn into such a jerk it beat and killed one of the other Red Tapajos. So I then moved him into my 125g frontosa tank (all 10"-13" fronts) just to let him calm down till I decided what to do with him. He sherreded the fins on one of the fronts. Now for the past 8 months he lives in my 240g very aggressive Hap&mbuna tank and no one messes with him. Most aggressive Geo I have ever seem I dunno what is wrong in his head be he just ain't right:crazy:
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com