I think you just over tighten it. I have 2 CFS500 and 4 CFS700 for over a year. Never had any serious issues. The only thing you need to make sure is that you tighten evenly. I tighten like your would a rim on a car. 2 opposite of each other. If the lid is tighten evenly then the seal will be tight. Doesn't need to be super gorilla tight!. I tighten just till it gets hard to turn with wet fingers then that's it. Over tightening can actually bow the lid and cause a leak around the seal. And in your case crack the lid