Official 2007-2008 NFL Thread

[bigspizz]

howard goes as far to say the peyton isn't even in the same leauge as brady, i wouldn't go that far, but he definetly is nowhere as good as brady the best Qb's in the leauge imo are-

#1 Tom brady
#2- Farve
#3 peyton and #3 is EXTremely generous.

and great Qb's can go for yards and Td's with any receiver not just a stud like harrison, ESPN puts him up with legends like marino, and people like him are there for constant great performance if they had a great reciever or just good one, and peyton can't be said in the same sentence as them or brady, brady gets the job done where it counts 3 SB rings say it all, peytons post season record is like 7-7, that's nowhere near great and barely even good.

Dan Marino never won a super bowl, that does NOT make him un-great....Brett Favre #2? Now if that isn't the most fair-weather rating in history, I don't know what is....He is having a story book season, but lets not get to ahead of our selves. What would your list have looked like last year or the year before? If Peyton was not on those lists (as #1) Then I digress.....

 

[---XR---]

watch him play in the playoffs, and than watch how ESPN advertises his skill, it pathetic really, he does a GOOD job most of the time, but not playoffs, but he is the dream child of espn and therefor many many sports fans, he is not close to one of the great QB's of all time, he is decent nothing more, not a clutch king superstar QB, would i prefer him over 75% of the leauges QB's- definetly, does he come close to even in the range of Tom brady, hell no.

 

[---XR---]

tell of show comparisons of brady and show how peyton is better than brady, if you think that your on drugs, or love espn a whole f-ing lot, just watch them play, there is no way you can say peyton is better, if you do you don't watch the NFL.

 

[bigspizz]

Peyton Manning is the best period...Brady is having a better year and that's it.....

 

[messytank]

pfft you guys are wrong... philip rivers is the best!!! and he will talk sh1t to opposing fans, now what?

 

[JD_MAN]

It would be hard for me to make a list of where I would rank all of the qb's (since I have been watching football...since the late 80's). I know Favre would be up there and definitely Montana...after that I don't know. Aikman would probably be on it, but it would be hard not to have Peyton up there.

Every QB has his ups and downs. It just depends on what you are rating them on...I guess.

 

[---XR---]

Peyton Manning is the best period...Brady is having a better year and that's it.....

do you have any good playoff evidence at all to back up this claim?

because it sounds like pure childishness posts, i like you spizz, but you really need to think about the facts on manning, he is a clown and a choker in the playoffs, not Mr.clutch king.

please start giveing hard evidence (*whisper lighty*- there is none btw ) or tell something to provve your point because basically your arguments are nothing, i'm not gonna ask you to repent your arguments just to think and watch peyton in the future-

this is what your doing spizz- ...

this is where your going-...

 

[rallysman]

do you have any good playoff evidence at all to back up this claim?

because it sounds like pure childishness posts, i like you spizz, but you really need to think about the facts on manning, he is a clown and a choker in the playoffs, not Mr.clutch king.

please start giveing hard evidence (*whisper lighty*- there is none btw ) or tell something to provve your point because basically your arguments are nothing, i'm not gonna ask you to repent your arguments just to think and watch peyton in the future-

this is what your doing spizz- ...

this is where your going-...

How does Brady taste?

 

[JD_MAN]

do you have any good playoff evidence at all to back up this claim?

because it sounds like pure childishness posts, i like you spizz, but you really need to think about the facts on manning, he is a clown and a choker in the playoffs, not Mr.clutch king.

please start giveing hard evidence (*whisper lighty*- there is none btw ) or tell something to provve your point because basically your arguments are nothing, i'm not gonna ask you to repent your arguments just to think and watch peyton in the future-

this is what your doing spizz- ...

this is where your going-...

It wasn't always just Manning that would choke. He had help from his defense and Mike Vanderjagt at times. It just seems that a lot of it falls back on Peyton.

 

[---XR---]

How does Brady taste?

har har har