Perch...which one is better?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Time for some clarification

"Chinese perch" is a lose term covering the genus of fish siniperca

Rallysman has the siniperca chuatsi, one of the more commonly available, also one that gets quite large, 24" specimens are not uncommon. But many of the other species in the group, including the Korean perch, siniperca scherzeri, whitei, herzi, roulei, obscura, etc...many of which do not grow past 16".

Nile perch is the one with a notorious reputation as the fish that has decimated the wild victorian cichlids in Lake Victoria. Which the fish themselves should not be blamed, but the humans that introduced the fish to the region for commercial purposes.

In captivity, a nile perch, which is lates niloticus, is a reasonably peaceful fish, rarely if any out in the hobby are over 30", when in fact many silver arowanas and pacus have been in the hobby and grown way past that mark, and no one is making a fuss about it, ultimately, we just have to be responsible for what we keep. If anyone has a nile perch that has outgrown their tank, give me a call, I'd be more than happy to take it off their hand.

On another note, there are also some Lates sp. angustifrons, mariae, microlepis that only gets to 3 feet or so. And last but not least, recently there has been a large influx of lates calcarifer, they can get just as large as a Lates niloticus.

Other fish that will out grow a "typical fish tank" that is often sold and seen available.

Pacu, arowanas, arapaima, most of the south american catfish, redtails, tiger shovel nose, planiceps, peacock bass. More pacus, red devils and even oscars are found in rivers and lakes, and you'll never find a nile perch!


Just a few ideas to think about before jumping to conclusions.
 
Thanks for that. Awesome info. Is it cool if I copy that to quote if I need to in the future? (credit would be given of course)
 
fugupuff;515108; said:
Time for some clarification

"Chinese perch" is a lose term covering the genus of fish siniperca

Rallysman has the siniperca chuatsi, one of the more commonly available, also one that gets quite large, 24" specimens are not uncommon. But many of the other species in the group, including the Korean perch, siniperca scherzeri, whitei, herzi, roulei, obscura, etc...many of which do not grow past 16".

Nile perch is the one with a notorious reputation as the fish that has decimated the wild victorian cichlids in Lake Victoria. Which the fish themselves should not be blamed, but the humans that introduced the fish to the region for commercial purposes.

In captivity, a nile perch, which is lates niloticus, is a reasonably peaceful fish, rarely if any out in the hobby are over 30", when in fact many silver arowanas and pacus have been in the hobby and grown way past that mark, and no one is making a fuss about it, ultimately, we just have to be responsible for what we keep. If anyone has a nile perch that has outgrown their tank, give me a call, I'd be more than happy to take it off their hand.

On another note, there are also some Lates sp. angustifrons, mariae, microlepis that only gets to 3 feet or so. And last but not least, recently there has been a large influx of lates calcarifer, they can get just as large as a Lates niloticus.

Other fish that will out grow a "typical fish tank" that is often sold and seen available.

Pacu, arowanas, arapaima, most of the south american catfish, redtails, tiger shovel nose, planiceps, peacock bass. More pacus, red devils and even oscars are found in rivers and lakes, and you'll never find a nile perch!


Just a few ideas to think about before jumping to conclusions.


WOW...Wes speaks :WHOA:
 
Rallysman has the siniperca chuatsi, one of the more commonly available, also one that gets quite large, 24" specimens are not uncommon. But many of the other species in the group, including the Korean perch, siniperca scherzeri, whitei, herzi, roulei, obscura, etc...many of which do not grow past 16".




Thanks for the education, I really appreciate all the knowledge! I already know that the "korean" perch is a little out of my budget at the moment, of the "smaller" perch you described which are the most similar in looks and temperment to the Siniperca Chuatsi and what is the availibilty of these like? and of course..........what kind of damage are we talking about here?$$$$$$$$$$$ please drop some more info for me !!!! I will attempt to research in the meantime, DOes anyone prefer the NILE ??? MMMMMMMonsters
 
tangenykan perch? where?
 
big E;515644; said:
of the "smaller" perch you described which are the most similar in looks and temperment to the Siniperca Chuatsi and what is the availibilty of these like? and of course..........what kind of damage are we talking about here?$$$$$$$$$$$ please drop some more info for me !!!! I will attempt to research in the meantime, DOes anyone prefer the NILE ??? MMMMMMMonsters

Siniperca whitei, one of the smaller sp., has been in stock at Rare Fish recently, not at this time though. My nile and barramundi are great fish I would never give them up. Nile's, all lates for that matter, are definitely more aggressive than siniperca sp.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com