Please read!

[importracer]

........................where's the MSG? and even if MSG is bad for us humans...how do you know it's bad for fish? You some kind of fish expert?

I think he is looking out to those who may be allergic to MSG...Kind of a heads up thing....But, yeah, I doubt any of us has ever eaten this stuff...I accidently lick my fingers without washing after feedings, but I do not get any of the headaches I get from eating at fast food places....

 

[SimonL]

MSG? No wonder it tastes so good...I mean, so my fish tell me...

 

[TurboVinny]

This is about Hikari food. Some of you have probably heard me talking about this in other threads but i m going to start a thread about it. Okay, Hikari food is baaad it has MSG in it which i m allergic to and if i eat MSG i cough uncontrollably for a while (not that i'd eat fish food) and even some people who aren't allergic to it react to it in different ways. So even if u have been feeding Hikari for awhile with no ill effects, i'd stop now.

what did it taste like?

 

[chicken_boy_Kurt]

It may not be in that one but it's in others. I m not a fish expert but tests have been done on mice with MSG and they were affected worse than humans (that matters in this post). If it causes people to react then why not fish. If anyone finds evidence that MSG is not bad for fish (with a link) I will apologize (if anyone cares about that).

 

[tunerX]

Send an email to Hikari. I bet they say you are full of it... but not with that language.

 

[SimonL]

Actually makes sense to me...Hikari food is like Crack for fish lol.

 

[DexGTR]

If it causes people to react then why not fish.

very good...very scientific approach...

anyway i found one with MSG...

Sinking Wafers®

Ingredients: fish meal, wheat-germ meal, wheat flour, alpha starch, soybean meal, fish oil, dried seaweed meal, krill meal, dried bakery product, brewer's dried yeast, spirulina, enzyme, astaxanthin, garlic, DL-methionine, monosodium glutamate, vitamins and minerals including stabilized vitamin C

now that i have helped you find the product you were bashing...please state your facts on why it's bad for fish...other than you are allergic to it.

BTW mice and fish are completely different animals...just an FYI

 

[Merbeast]

It may not be in that one but it's in others. I m not a fish expert but tests have been done on mice with MSG and they were affected worse than humans (that matters in this post). If it causes people to react then why not fish. If anyone finds evidence that MSG is not bad for fish (with a link) I will apologize (if anyone cares about that).

You are asking us to disprove your hypothesis? Um, usually the onus is on the proponent of a hypothesis to prove it, not on everyone else to disprove it. For example, I could say "Pluto is made of pure plutonium, and I will not believe otherwise until you prove me wrong." You should have had some proof before you maligned Hikari. I bet a lawyer could have a field day with you making statements about Hikari like that (if they cared).

 

[SimonL]

I'm allergic to cats...heads up guys! Don't feed cats to your fish!

 

[cszachury]

Humm.... Waiting.