Thank you. 72+ hours in and there are no more eggs on the pvc pipe. When I checked on them about 12 hours ago most were still there and you could see they were fertilized and had black on the inside. Guess I never really timed how long it takes but do you think they've hatched and fell underneath the pvc or the parents ate them? Would it hurt anything if I moved the pvc where they were at carefully? Most cichlids I've bred I've been lucky enough they've spawned either on a clay saucer or in a pot.... not on a round piece of pvc lol