RTC owners

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
bigredjeep;1336191; said:
he was telling me how to build a tank where i could incorporate a glass side...he specifically said it wasnt and ideal situation but it could be done i asked a question and he answered it and i know what hes sayin..i wont be getting a RTC so theres no use to to critisise anyone in terms of advice, i jus wanted to hear what yall kept your RTCs in and how big it was and maybe see some pics
wolf if u get that tank and dont post pics im going to be pissed!

This isn't anything more than discussing of what is proper for THIS type of fish, Credit should be given for the whole tank idea and no one is discrediting that what so ever... simply put though... a red tail in a 4X4X2 just is not an option... 8 X 4 I guess I could see it for the average person that will prop only keep it for a few years then try to find it a new home or can only keep it alive for X# of years. not an ideal situation but do-able.
 
It's OK big...at least you understand what I was pointing out. The vast majority of RTC's sold in LFS's never even have the sort of accomidations that I'm talking about..let alone the in ground pools most people seem to assume they need for life. Our fish, to us, are no less familly members than our wolves and dogs and we have always and will always do what's necessary to make them happy and confortable for life.

We don't discard familly members because they become inconveniant.

We had a lot of the same flack about a TSN we picked up...It was going to outgrow our 240 gallon tank in three weeks and require a 10' x 6' x 4' tank by the end of the year...yadda yadda yadda.
I've kept fish for slightly over 30 years so I'm far from a beginer in the hobby.
The TSN by the way has been with us about a year now and has grown about 3" to 4" and is still quite comfortable in his original tank along with Lucy...my RTC. Plenty of swimming room, great diet and water conditions ECT.

The pallette tank was a suggestion for an acceptable TEMPORARY housing that wouldnt break the bank and was never intended to be presented as anything else. We have a couple of these as emergancy tanks and plan to get a couple more as transportation tanks when we move.

The information I posted on this thread was only ment as a counterpoint to the normal horror storys, so common on this site about fish growing a foot a month.

Granted people usually buy these types of fish without having a clue as to thier eventual needs but a certian amount of realistic information is necessory.

They CAN in fact be kept in home aquaria for life if the owner is willing to upgrade as necessary. I've personally had fish live in my care for 15...18...and 22 years respectivly. This is far longer than the majority of people here have even been in the hobby.

Additionally I don't find the use of converted kiddy pools to be at all responsable even though they give a lot of swimming room because of the temporary nature of the construction. They present a danger of failure from day one that only increases the longer they are kept in servace.

I didn't respond to this, by the way, in a defencive manor but rather to clear up a few obvious misconceptions about what I posted. I KNOW my fish are well kept...healthy...happy...and set for life no mater what they need.

Outdoor ponds have thier own set of dangers including local wildlife...storms...temperiture control and the possibillity of introduced wind born pesticides. I've delt with this quite a bit in Koi ponds I've set up over the years.

The container tank project is moving along really well and although it still looks to be a good year or so in the future it's growing closer and closer to reality.
 
As I mentioned previously I respect your opinions and experience, and don't beleive that you are wrong in saying that it would be a good temp home for an RTC however I don't see how I misunderstood your statement?

Wolf3101;1334830; said:
I could easilly see a RTC living it's whole life in a 250 gallon pallette tank....

4' x 4' x 2'...nylon (available on Ebay for just under $200.00) In fact this would only enhance the interaction IMO.

As for the Flack you've received for your TSN... What does that have to do with this? I'm not talking out of my ass with respect to RTC's I have tons of research and personal knowledge to back me up. I'm not saying anything with respect to Inflatable pools or outdoor ponds, simply that they need space which your statement simply did not correspond with. There is no intent to discredit you, your personal fish keeping style or the love you have for your fish, if I was trying to do that it would be because I did not respect you and I absolutely do respect you! I as well am not trying to continue down a path with misinformation but simply ensure that our message is correct and clear. It’s one thing to consider the temporary needs of our fish but we also need to ensure that the inevitable is noted as these fish aren’t your average Goldfish, and can live with you for 20+ years and can get to be massive. As your statement mentioned… these fish CAN be kept in home aquaria for life IF your willing to upgrade accordingly, This statement was never in question and is agreed amongst every RTC owner on the forum.
That said,
I’m looking forward to hearing more of your container tank as well as how you are going to accomplish your move, it will be interesting to see how you choose to deal with the interior of the tank and filtration which was going to be all over head as I recall from your posts.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com