Ok, thank you for all the suggestions! I’m still open to more, but I think I have a pretty good idea of what I want:
Option 1: Senegal bichir with an African brown knife OR some kind of puffer
Option 2: A red bellied piranha, possibly with a couple dither fish
I think that’s what I want, of course I’m still open to more suggestions, but out of the great ones I’ve got, I think this is gunna be what I would like best. Thank everyone for the advice and suggestions!
I wouldn't count on a permit as easy to get. I would rule out option 2 by 99%.