some people are just stupid...

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I don't see the problem here, it's not like it's being harvested en mass to make jewelery or to make some other consumer product. Assuming a magical man in the sky does rapture his true believers away in 2012 or whenever people think the world is going to end this time, the rest of us are going to want to try to take care of this particular watery rock flying through space and we will need to learn more about it to do so.

In the grand scheme of things samples taken from slow growing corals for the sake of protecting them in the future are more than appropriate.. If you need something to get riled up about you can look at things like wild tuna, the decimation of virtually every species the Chinese consider novelty foods or claim have "medicinal" qualities, or the humanitarian issues plagueing the better part of Africa..

If researchers with legitimate work to do aren't allowed to do it we probably won't make it another 1000 years, but there's no reason a species that can get to the moon shouldn't last for as long as we keep from killing ourselves off.
 
It could be debated that scientists removing that peice of coral will help lead to rules being put into place for preservation of this coral. 100 years of growth cut away to discover a coral thought to be 70 years old is 4,000 years old...maybe that will help it's entire species in becoming protected...

It's really not that big of a deal if it's for scientific research.
 
knifegill;3562851; said:
Just like Auschwitz? Of course, silly me.

Yes, that's pretty much exactly the same as removing a fragment of an organism with no brain or complex nervous system.
 
find out what the real world is like.
The real world? I see camo and a gun in your avatar. Your world is likely fear-based, with a twist of anger. There actually is no real world, anyway. Even among twins who have lived side by side, perception of reality differs. But if there is one thing we can agree on, it's the impressiveness of that ancient coral, whether or not we agree about what was done to it.
 
alright, everyone shut up. this was rather interesting till people started flaming each other.
 
Comparing fragging a coral to the holocaust is pretty offensive...

I say cutting that piece of coral off was a good thing, and it's impressive that the coral is so old - without doing so scientists would not have known how old they are. This could have lead to an entire specimen being collected without knowledge down the line, which will likely not happen now - thanks to that study.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com