Stupid Carpintis!!!! Need advice...

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
balton777;1724013;1724013 said:
I have two 4" Carpintis in a 253 gallon CA/SA community tank setup with no problems yet. They're tankmates are 8 other CA/SA's. I'm hoping that by growing them out along with other same size cichlids, they (and the others) will get used to having tankmates and just establish a pecking order oppossed to outright killer instinct.
So what would you do with a bada$$ like mine?? i really dont want him in a tank alone but its starting to stress my out my aro and i definately dont want to have a jumpy silver aro. if i really have to choose, i will choose the aro because he's gonna be the center piece when he gets big.

and then get maybe a 55g just for the carpintis. i really dont wanna trade him in as ive gotten attached to him/her...

Oh, and this guy REALLY hates my clown loaches. he will literally chase them all over the tank. with most other fish, he will just chase and nip until they get out of his half of the tank, but not with the CL's!!!
 
You could try trading him out for another one. Sometimes 2 seemingly exact same fish will have very different levels of aggression. :confused:
 
Those are all male jcar looks like you've got a rouge on your hands.
 
Balton makes a good point, but if you wish to keep him try disturbing the tank in a major way meaning the aquascaping. if not pull him out for a few day and let the other find their spot then place him back in. and again if all fails trade him out.
 
scubasteve06;1724107; said:
Those are all male jcar looks like you've got a rouge on your hands.

Cool! yeah im sure not all carpintis are this way. maybe its just his personality. so what do you look at to sex a carpintis??

calicichlid;1724121; said:
Balton makes a good point, but if you wish to keep him try disturbing the tank in a major way meaning the aquascaping. if not pull him out for a few day and let the other find their spot then place him back in. and again if all fails trade him out.

thats a good idea, i might try that. actually, all these guys are due to be transferred to my 210 this weekend, so i wonder if that would change things. if nothing works, ill just keep him in my 30g until i can find something a little bigger just for him. Do you guys think a 55g would work just for this guy?
 
jcardona1;1724144; said:
Cool! yeah im sure not all carpintis are this way. maybe its just his personality. so what do you look at to sex a carpintis??



thats a good idea, i might try that. actually, all these guys are due to be transferred to my 210 this weekend, so i wonder if that would change things. if nothing works, ill just keep him in my 30g until i can find something a little bigger just for him. Do you guys think a 55g would work just for this guy?


A 55 solo would be fine for him just give him some nice driftwood and some holes to hide around. Try next time u get him to eat a lot look at his vent and if it is bulbous and round and not more of a stinger looking thing then it is female if it is more stinger looking it is male.
 
scubasteve06;1724153;1724153 said:
A 55 solo would be fine for him just give him some nice driftwood and some holes to hide around. Try next time u get him to eat a lot look at his vent and if it is bulbous and round and not more of a stinger looking thing then it is female if it is more stinger looking it is male.
Will do, thanks for the info! :cheers:
 
jcardona1;1724144; said:
Cool! yeah im sure not all carpintis are this way. maybe its just his personality. so what do you look at to sex a carpintis??



thats a good idea, i might try that. actually, all these guys are due to be transferred to my 210 this weekend, so i wonder if that would change things. if nothing works, ill just keep him in my 30g until i can find something a little bigger just for him. Do you guys think a 55g would work just for this guy?
first of all 30G on his own wont hurt him he could get to 6-7" at max in there before rehoming in a diff tank.

you could try reaquascaping as mentioned before, breaking up the terriotory and making more hinding spaces and caves you could also use some tubes or something that the loaches can fit in which he cant. after reaquascaping the tank and moving/changing everything around put him back in the tank in a week or soand see how things get on.

if all else fails you could do him a 55G which would set him for life i think, maybe even get a female in later stages of his life who knows.

i suspect he is becoming more aggressive now because he is getting on the verge of maturity and wanting to guard his territory and show everyone else who's boss.

if you put them in the 210 all the other fish will have more room to run away so this should help aswell.

you can tell the sex of them fairly easy enough by my knowledge anyways- MALE = more spangles on the gill plates, longer and pointier dorsal and anal fins, and venting them is also another way to tell (maybe to small at this age tho males is thiner and pointier), also nuchal humps tend to be more visible reaching the 6-7" mark.

FEMALE = not so many spangles on the gill plates, slightly shorter more rounded off dorsal and anal fins, and venting them aswell (females have a fatter tube which is hard to spot unless in breeding mode in which case it is fatter and shorter)

(please correct me if i am wrong)

below is a picture of a definate male hope this helps
 
thanks mbuna, that was some really good info!
 
jcardona1;1724208; said:
thanks mbuna, that was some really good info!
no worries good to help;)
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com