I agree with you about the supports on the sides holding up the weight of the tank. But to say your stand is the same as the stand in the original post is a stretch. The one you made is a much higher quality build than the stand in the pics op posted just below. The difference is how the support rests underneath the horizontal face on yours vs the side extending above the horizontal face. I agree with what you are saying, but the “nay sayer” in my posts have less to do with the “mdf “ itself and more about the cheap construction of the original stand. Indeed the stand you built is sturdy and built for a weight of a fish tank. Whereas the original “stand” doesn’t look like a stand as much as it looks like a cheap ikea desk. My statement about the original desk being weak to hold the tank, “stands” (pun intended).
I wouldn’t put any fish tank on that stand 1 14crazychris it doesn’t look like it was built for a fish tank at all. The stand in C cvar post is well built and designed for a tank. They are not the sam. In any way other than the materials used.
someone may get away with it, but all it takes is one moment of an equipment failure to cause a huge disaster. Example on the left side of the stand the melamine is peeling back, if that gets wet from a faulty filter, it will swell then it will compromise the wood, once that happens it will be easy for the fasteners to cave (the wood surrounding the fasteners) and done.
you do whatever you want, you may get away with it. I just know many people on this site have given me advise that I didn’t like, I decided I need to find out for myself, then when I find that they were right, I wished that I would have just listened rather than losing that fish, or whatever it was that I didn’t listen to sound advice.
thank you for the feedback, the stand was built by one of if not the biggest aquarium manufacturers in my country but I agree it’s not the best. I know what you mean about not listening to advice, and then making the mistakes! Been there done that got the t shirt haha. I’m going to go ahead with my reinforcing strategy anyway as I have the wood lying about. Then I’ll decide what I think about it. I mean worse case scenario I can keep the tank on the floor until I get the upgrade lol. This afternoon I’m going to be leak testing the aquarium anyway as it wasn’t brand new, see how that goes first haha.
thanks