What are your overrated foods for fish?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

FINWIN

Alligator Gar
MFK Member
Dec 21, 2018
5,921
9,331
188
Washington DC
For me, these are the ones

Massivore. It stinks like an elephant's ass, and none of my fish will touch the stuff. Hyped as irresistible.

Another overblown food is bloodworms. My fish will eat them about the same as tubifex. Ok, but nothing to get crazy about.

Freeze dried earthworms for large fish. You could soak those suckers for a month. They resemble beef jerky. My O would have no part of them.

Crickets. A mixed bag. Eaten at times then ignored.

Freeze dried soldier larvae. May as well be goat turds.
 
For me, these are the ones

Massivore. It stinks like an elephant's ass, and none of my fish will touch the stuff. Hyped as irresistible.

Another overblown food is bloodworms. My fish will eat them about the same as tubifex. Ok, but nothing to get crazy about.

Freeze dried earthworms for large fish. You could soak those suckers for a month. They resemble beef jerky. My O would have no part of them.

Crickets. A mixed bag. Eaten at times then ignored.

Freeze dried soldier larvae. May as well be goat turds.

For me personally, don't even touch 'live feedings'. Parasites and a whole array of nasty infections.
 
Everything I feed gets nailed, and quick, so I can't really say my choice of foods are overrated, as my fish love them all. But.....

One food my fish also love, especially my giant gourami, are fruits and veggies. As much as my fish also love these food items, and as "good" as they are reported to be for their digestive tracts, they make a real mess of my mechanical filters for a while after feeding.

These foods seem to go right through the fish and they crap like crazy after digestion, or part digestion looking at some of the remnants.

Fruits and veggies play little part in their diet now, except for my GG, who I'll target feed by hand once in a while with the odd green titbit.

I believe that terrestrial based plant matter is simply not that good for fish, yet lots of hobbyists feed it regularly, extremely overrated imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: A201 and tlindsey
Crickets: My fish love them. But they get everywhere, half of them escape and for days afterwards I have to search for them in strange places around the house.

Frogs: Predators love them. But some of them escape too. And if not eaten straight away, they really smell bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: A201 and tlindsey
One food my fish also love, especially my giant gourami, are fruits and veggies. As much as my fish also love these food items, and as "good" as they are reported to be for their digestive tracts, they make a real mess of my mechanical filters for a while after feeding. If I have any nori around from sushi - that doesn't seem to cause problems if all peices are bite sized.
Yeah, if I'm cutting a cuke anyway I might cut a couple slices for the goldfish and pleco, they do seem to like them, but yeah I'll be cleaning out more than the leftovers in the morning so I don't. Lettuce can go straight to hell.
I think wild food is underrated. Starting a culture from wild is better still, yes the risks of disease are real, but creatures who eat other creatures tend to eat the small, sick, and injured until they are old and out competed by the young.
 
Last edited:
Crickets: My fish love them. But they get everywhere, half of them escape and for days afterwards I have to search for them in strange places around the house.

Frogs: Predators love them. But some of them escape too. And if not eaten straight away, they really smell bad.

Interesting you mention this...my O would eat the crickets but break the legs off!
 
Hikari is hands down top of my list, just look at the ingredients vs true premium foods. Overrated because so many people recommend it. For me it's not just what's on the label:

In what I might call my fish food dark ages I used to use it, not because I was a fan, but at the time it was the 'best' I could find here locally after moving from Florida. But that was until the time years ago I got some really beautiful, wild Copadichromis mloto, which I noticed looked a lot more dull after a couple of months in my tank. Long story short, I fixed it with better food, leading to getting interested in the subject, doing a lot of brand testing, etc.
 
Frozen foods! Specifically, I am referring to commercially-available, small frozen items like bloodworms, brine shrimp, etc.

Yeah, they may seem convenient...just drop a cube into the tank and sit back to watch...but this stuff is essentially a frozen cube of inedible water-polluting juice, containing a very small proportion of actual solid food. If we are talking about larger items like silversides, krill, etc. it's not too bad; thaw them in a glass of room-temperature tap water, then feed the big chunks of food.

But the small stuff is just nasty. Drop a cube or two into a glass of water, let it thaw and settle, pour off the liquid, refill with clean water and then feed with an eyedropper, spoon, baster, whatever. You don't get a whole lot of food into the fish this way. The original thawed juice can be used as the liquid component of a homemade gel food, and this at least allows your fish to access some of those nutrients, rather than just throwing them away or introducing them in liquid form to the tank to cause pollution. Incidentally, the second-most-overrated fish food...i.e. flakes!...can also be utilized in that mixture.

The worst...and best...frozen small food, IMHO, is frozen baby brine shrimp. Worst...because it is essentially impossible to thaw/settle it like most others; the individual particles are just too tiny. And best...because a cube thrown into a fry grow-out tank creates a feeding frenzy unlike anything else. Yes, all that disgusting juice is being dispersed into the tank while you do this...but for a fry grow-out I usually do 90% water changes every couple of days, so the dissolved pollutants remain manageable.

The absolute best part of frozen foods is saving the thawed juice in the freezer until you have enough for a gelatin food mixture. Thaw it out on the kitchen counter before use. Your spouse will find it, peer at it, smell it...and the howling will begin. Presto! That will be the worst thing that happens to you that day; knowing that literally everything else afterwards will be an improvement is very soothing. :)
 
Frozen Brine shrimp and Frozen Bloodworms are overrated imo due to nutritional value.
 
  • Like
Reactions: A201
MonsterFishKeepers.com