Whats your view on illegal fish keepers?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Whats your view on illegal fish keepers?

  • Love them (im jealous)

    Votes: 64 27.6%
  • Hate them (its a dis-service to the hobby)

    Votes: 27 11.6%
  • I dont care, youve just wasted 30 seconds of my life...

    Votes: 141 60.8%

  • Total voters
    232
Bobnova;897539; said:
Their official classification is "extinct in the wild".
The reason?
Someone (i'm betting the USA was involved, personally) decided that they could feed a lot of starving mexicans by stocking the ponds and rivers that the ameca splendens was native to with small mouth bass.
The bass, of course, ate all the amecas..

i really hope i dont have to close this thread...

Bacteria Culture.JPG
 
I dont think ameca splendens are illegal to posess.There is a group called the ARK project that has been distributing them at club auctions for the purpose of preserving the species.I purchased 5 of them a few weeks ago and plan on breeding them,then contacting the group to see about trading fry to keep them from getting inbred,and "passing some forward".Seemed to me an interesting and fun way to give something back to the hobby that I enjoy so much.
 
gomezladdams;898039; said:
I dont think ameca splendens are illegal to posess.There is a group called the ARK project that has been distributing them at club auctions for the purpose of preserving the species.I purchased 5 of them a few weeks ago and plan on breeding them,then contacting the group to see about trading fry to keep them from getting inbred,and "passing some forward".Seemed to me an interesting and fun way to give something back to the hobby that I enjoy so much.

We have ameca splendens at the store where I work now.
 
interesting to see where this thread went.

for the record, i've been to a couple different driving schools and have done some sanctioned high speed racing (bonneville speed week, silver state classic). and all of my high speed runs where done on a length of the freeway that i have driven for 15+ years. and its not like i was hitting 150 everyday. lol, overreact much around here, i'm not some 16 year old kid making hihg end runs during rush hour! besides, i know sportbike guys who make runs like that EVERYDAY and never run into problems because they know their machine and know the area they are driving fast.

getting back to the topic what i hate the most about this hobby are the irresponsible people that dump non native species in local streams/rivers/lakes and the idiots that keep two oscars in a 20gl for years on end. those two situations and situations like them are what frustrate me the most about this hobby.

someone who owns a RTG for 15 years in its own 180gl isn't a criminal in my opinion, but someone who respects the hobby and knows what they are doing.

one last thing, for those on here that are saying we shouldn't own them because the law says so, while i agree that certain laws are unbendable, when you consider that some of the laws regarding fish are horribly outdated and completely inconsistent with the rest of the WORLD, it makes your arguement pretty weak.
 
gomezladdams;898039; said:
I dont think ameca splendens are illegal to posess.There is a group called the ARK project that has been distributing them at club auctions for the purpose of preserving the species.I purchased 5 of them a few weeks ago and plan on breeding them,then contacting the group to see about trading fry to keep them from getting inbred,and "passing some forward".Seemed to me an interesting and fun way to give something back to the hobby that I enjoy so much.

that would be an awesome idea! ill have to start looking for them now. do they seem hard to breed?
 
Polypterus;897584; said:
Lets get things right here...First of all Ameca splendens are still found in the wild but are very much threatened with extinction..It was not Smallmouth bass but Largemouth bass..

These Largemouth where Bucket dumps by locals and not Government sanctioned. The US nor Mexican government had nothing to do with this.

Get your facts straight

this is a great example of why certain fish are illegal in certain areas.
invasive species can devistate a native population.
 
From yesterday,

Polypterus;897569; said:
This is such an amusing thread to read...

I just love the inconsistencies, double standards, ignorance and all around disregard for federal and state wildlife law...Nice to know how many see laws meant to protect Native ecosystems as just a road bump or inconvenience to your selfish material pleasures. Really shows you well and shows how little you get the seriousness of the issues that have enacted these laws in the first place.

Do any of you get it ????

And then from 4-23,
Polypterus;822878; said:
I personally would be a hypocrite to say I have followed the letter of the law on this myself..I have kept both Exotic goby species found in the Great lakes..This was before the newer more strict laws but it was even then a bit of a NO NO to do so.

http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?p=822878#post822878

Interesting how it's okay for you to break the laws you choose to, yet condemn others for the same practice. You were right, you would be a hypocrite.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com