Which canister filter?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Magnum 350 are horrible filters. Never buy one. Trust me.

Sent from my DROIDX using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

A little info may justify your post. Why would anyone just read 'trust me' and do so? I think it's fair to share an experience and why you think that; especially since many of us have used them and have had great luck.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Magnum 350 are horrible filters. Never buy one. Trust me.

Sent from my DROIDX using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

an FX5 is too big to fit in my stand so i cant go that route. What would you advise instead?
 
I am guessing you have gravel in your tank. Add a couple powerful power heads to push the water around. Switch to sand so crap stays on top and can hit the water flow easy. More powerful sump pump to add flow also.?



Sent from my Touchpad using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Ok magnum. Have one and first the little basket deal is stupid cheap. Falls apart and overtime your carbon more or less falls out because what little pressure it has pushes the plastic strainer inward to make a mess of it. Even if you pack it full of media. The plastic parts all all cheap crack and the seams spread start on the tubes. The other cartridges are nice. Hard to clean out. Take allong time to rinse all the stuff off. But clog super super fast. They say good for 100 gallons. On a 30 gallon tank I can't even get a week of filtering and that is with an on back filter working also. Overall small size and filtering capacity. For the cost 120.00 an fx5 is about 230 and will do the work of four magnums any day. I might use a magnum in a salt water tank with some rock in it for Bio but never as a real filter.

Sent from my Touchpad using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Also how is your sump setup? Do you have a filter sock or two? Pic please.

Sent from my Touchpad using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
You can reference a fx5 review thread if you want to see and read more about the difference with the 350 filter.

Sent from my DROIDX using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
I am guessing you have gravel in your tank. Add a couple powerful power heads to push the water around. Switch to sand so crap stays on top and can hit the water flow easy. More powerful sump pump to add flow also.?



Sent from my Touchpad using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

I have sand substrate. I have a wet/dry sump with a magdrive 18 pump to return to tha tank. For the last 6 months or so i have been playing with 3 different powerheads inside the tank trying to arrange it in such a way as to stimulate water movement to get the ditritus up and over the overflow.

The main issue is that the tank is 8 feel long. return on one end and drain on the other. It does what is supposed to do to an extent and a lot of the crap does go up and over the overflow and into the sump, but a lot of it hangs out by the return side of the tank and settles at the bottom.

The powerheads get the ditritus in the water column, but i just cant aim them in such a way to get it to the overflow. Instead the crap just spins in circles around the return.

I do not have filter socks, but i do have 3 layers of filter pads in the top champer of the sump before it hits the bio balls. The 3rd pad down is 10 micron and the top two are more pourous the catch only the larger crap.

Basically, I am fed up messing with powerheads. I am ready to get a canister that will actually suck crap and I can keep it closer to the floor of the aquarium to get the crap off the sand....

I know it would be ideal to get an FX5 or equivelent but it just won't fit under my stand because the doors are too small. The magnum 350 is probably too small even for just adding mech filtration. I think the eheim 2217 is what i am going to end up with here. At least that can also handle some bio if my sump ever goes down for some reason.
 
What about a Marineland Magnum 350? They're small, easy to maintain, and do a pretty kickass job. I run 3 of them on a 125 and have never had an issue. I'm fairly certain I've seen them used for ~50 bucks.

I have one of these on my 150. With a buttload of current, this thing keeps my water stunningly clear.
 
alright, lets start over. What i am looking for is the best filter with highest rating that will fit under my cabinet. I am between the Rena XP4 and Eheim 2217. The Rena is going to be a little more expensive, but is actually rated for a larger tank and probably more appropriate for my size. Of those two, which is best?
 
The xp4 is a decent filter for bio but the flow rate is junk. But the real question is why do you want all that stuff in your filter? Just because you can't see it in the tank doesn't mean it isn't fouling your water. Just arrange the powerheads so it all congregates in one spot and vacuum it up. You and your fish are a lot better off this way. Too many people rely too heavily on filters when in all reality you are better off just vacuuming it up. It means less nitrates and fewer filter cleanings. Mechanical filtration is the least important factor in proper filtration IMO you are better off with good bio and lots of waterchanges:)


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com