which gar?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
troppond;4937770; said:
wow, guys over on the natives forum said they'd be fine if it didnt freeze over. Now I am leaning more towards a musky

please see the extensive discussion on temperature ranges for gars - it's only a thread or two below this one.

keep in mind even if you get a muskellunge you would have to make sure it got enough food in the growing season in order to survive the winter - they feed during winter more frequently than gars, but captive fishes do behave differently than wild fishes on several levels--
--solomon
 
Okay, the temperature question came up in another recent thread so here goes:

You should be fine keeping an alligator gar in the pond year-round provided that you ensure that its at a large enough size and has ample time to get used to living outside. Their historical range once extended all the way into southern Ohio, and there have been many introductions of them further north. I'd say make sure that it's at least 12" long (bigger is preferred) prior to adding it. Be sure to keep it on live food in the grow-out if you do not intend on feeding it in the pond by giving it prepared foods and/or pellets rather than letting it hunt for other fish. Also be sure to match the temperature in its grow-out aquarium to that of the pond before adding it. Lastly, add it to the pond weeks (preferably months) before the water temperature starts to drop for Fall in order for it to be prepared for the coming cold months.

Having some method of keeping the pond from fully freezing over is beneficial and will help to ensure that the alligator gar (or any gar) survives the entire winter by allowing for better gas exchange. I personally do not have anything that keeps my pond from fully freezing over, and my two 16" YOY longnose gars are still doing fine (just checked them earlier this week when the ice melted for a day).

If you don't feel like risking it with an alligator gar, then get longnose gars, shortnose gars, or true spotted gars (not mislabeled Florida gars). All of these have natural ranges that extend into where you are or even further north into Canada.

That's just my 2¢.
 
Lately it seems like there have been a lot of people in the gar sub-forum asking for advice on like the most basic and non-interactive way to throw a gar into a hole in the ground -- I am not calling the OP out specifically and it is good that people ask questions -- but just because gar are hardy fish does not mean they are ideal for a low-maintenance pond... they are not beginner fish, plus... why not just heat your pond so your fish can thrive?

Sorry to derail and again OP this was directed at the forum this week in general, not you specifically. Just wanted to get that off my chest.
 
no offense taken madding, but this is a 1000$+ hole in the ground haha. Just every year I make the pond bigger during Spring. In its current location this should be its max size. Every year I've been kind of rushed but this year I have all the time in the world. Its a fact that the average person builds 3 pond before they are happy, and this is the 4th pond. The pond has had ccountless hours of mmaintenance and care. And I have kept natives, tropicals, and koi in this pond. And just wondering but monsterminis how is a 5 ft alligator gar fine but a 5 ft musky or 4 ft pike isnt? I mean its going to be 12x7?
 
Can anyone set me up with someone that will sell gator gar? This pond will be fully cycled and ready for the main fish by late april or may, Wiggles, if you know of anyone selling them please contact me once I have it up and running, Ill PM you. Can't wait im donewith digging!!!!
 
troppond;4939560; said:
no offense taken madding, but this is a 1000$+ hole in the ground haha. Just every year I make the pond bigger during Spring. In its current location this should be its max size. Every year I've been kind of rushed but this year I have all the time in the world. Its a fact that the average person builds 3 pond before they are happy, and this is the 4th pond. The pond has had ccountless hours of mmaintenance and care. And I have kept natives, tropicals, and koi in this pond. And just wondering but monsterminis how is a 5 ft alligator gar fine but a 5 ft musky or 4 ft pike isnt? I mean its going to be 12x7?

troppond;4939589; said:
Can anyone set me up with someone that will sell gator gar? This pond will be fully cycled and ready for the main fish by late april or may, Wiggles, if you know of anyone selling them please contact me once I have it up and running, Ill PM you. Can't wait im donewith digging!!!!

What Madding was getting at is that many people think that because gars are reputed to be like tanks therefore you can just plop them in pretty much any freshwater body of water, no matter what the temperature is, and go. In reality, they are like tanks if they have been acclimated to the conditions and are provided with ample food and space. They don't handle rapid changes very well at all, but they can adjust to certain conditions if they are given enough time to slowly do so. They're extremely adaptable fish, but they're still not invincible.

I honestly wouldn't keep anything over 3' in that pond if you don't intend on feeding them anything other than the other fish that are going to be in there. You'll want to try to build a food chain of sorts to ensure that there will always be an ample supply of food for the gar. I'd say start by adding a bunch of minnows (shiners, etc.), then adding a small school of adult bluegills (specifically bluegills, not other sunfish) a few weeks later, then add a few bullhead catfish (all of the same species), then finally add a single gar after all the other fish have been in the pond for a few weeks. All of the fish that I mentioned before make up the bulk of the diets of wild gars in different regions of North America. The goal is to be sure that there are plenty of smaller fish for the gar to eat, and to also be sure that the other fish are doing fine prior to adding the gar.

In either pond, you'll want to have plenty of plants along the edges of the pond, ome floating plants, and some submerged plants. Underwater structures such as driftwood will be greatly appreciated by all of the fish, so consider provided some form of underwater shelter as well. These additions will help to keep the other fish that act as the gars food from getting completely wiped out.

If you plan on feeding any fish over 3', then be prepared to have some heavy filtration on that pond to prevent waste from building up. It may not affect the gar at first, but it will kill off the other fish and eventually the gar.

I'm not aware of anyone who has alligator gar for sale currently, but I know that Aquascape has them from time to time. If you choose to go for a smaller species of gar, then check with some of the other vendors on here such as Snookn21, and also be sure to check TFD because they sometimes have gars for sale.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com