which to keep..Dovii or Umbee?

[suPaduPA]

Have a 300g for only one of them. Which to keep?..bought 2 umbees from Rapps but wasnt expecting to actually get a male..Dovii is also from Rapps..(sorry for quality of pictures..not good with pictures)

Umbee: 5inches (Male or Female?)..*picture does umbee's color no justice*

Dovii: 6-7inches *pictures does Dovii no justice**

AND while I'm at it..here are my other two CA/SA cichlid both from Rapps also..
Vieja Red Head: 8-9inches

RTM: 3-4inches

 

[Camphilophus]

Normally I'd say umbie, but.. That dovii is nice. My vote is keep the dovii even though everyone has them.

 

[famous323]

THE DOVII IS STUNNING KEEP IT

 

[Jakob]

Keep em both for a start, split the tank til they are 13-14", if that wont work then go with the dovii cause its a great specimen.

 

[mattison187]

keep the umbee and sell me the dovii

 

[QueenslandeR]

keep them both and sell the redhead if u really have to keep one i'd say the umbie, lately its as if every second person owns a dovii

 

[suPaduPA]

keep them both and sell the redhead if u really have to keep one i'd say the umbie, lately its as if every second person owns a dovii

Yea i've been seeing that too..i want to keep both but dont have the space..i want to grow em out till they hit 10inches or more but its going to also be harder to sell em at that size..I'm leaning towards the Umbee more..because of Roliva's shadow(RIP)..but i'm afraid it might turn out to be a female at the end....

 

[Mudfrog]

I prefer Dovii so I say go that route.. that's just me though.

 

[cornbread_5]

i think you should keep them both

 

[I<3fish]

Yeah, just put a divider down the middle.