WILL THIS WORK?! Jag,Oscar,FlowerH,RedDevil,GreenTerror,Texus,butte rcufi

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
This is like looking Hulk Hogan, Rowdy Rowdy Piper, the Shiek, Andre the Giant, and the Ultimate Warrior in a studio apartment with only one bathroom. After all the kiss and chase is done, they will just plain kill each other.
 
First let me agree with everyone else that your asking for disaster.

However, I've kept the first 3 plus more in a 90 (two jags though) that was the 4 foot size though. I made sure my filtration was adequate and had an FX-5 and AC110 on there, and really didn't have many problems, as long as the clay pot was placed correctly, however that part was so essential it was unbelievable. Temperament is going to play a huge role, and I don't recommend trying all bc of the requirements of each, and even more so bc I think the tank should be longer. I believe if you modify your list somewhat, that it could be reasonably done though.
 
oscarcrazy;3248919; said:
This is like looking Hulk Hogan, Rowdy Rowdy Piper, the Shiek, Andre the Giant, and the Ultimate Warrior in a studio apartment with only one bathroom. After all the kiss and chase is done, they will just plain kill each other.

A couple of those guys are already dead:nilly:
 
Has this guy been banned yet?
 
wow this is animal cruelty bro... why?
cause u know fish are gunna die!
some of those fish just dont mix well... for example the flowerhorn!
dude BIG MisTAKE
 
Sometimes when you pack them it in like that they don't fight as much, but that is never a great idea. I think that is way way to small though.. I have seen plenty of overstocked 180's pull off the impossible, individual fish are different. Search around..the overstocked threads. This thread was pointless and will be deleted very soon, It will only anger members who see it. Just imo I'd go with the red devil and flowerhorn ending in a showdown after all others bite it. Temper would decide the winner, but if it were my old one he would be the last standing. (so maybe I'm being bias.)
 
Adhlc;3249384; said:
Has this guy been banned yet?

You don't know how to tell if someone is banned or not?

Why would he banned anyhow? :duh:
 
I almost guarantee failure. Someone who even attempts this won't know enough to manage that bioload.

Reminds me of my first cichlid experience before I did my research, had a RD go all "highlander" in my tank. The lesson wasn't worth the lives it cost.
 
i agree with the packing them in but a 3ft??? id be more worried about the fish stunting within a week of being in there IF they survive.

like i see his point but not with those fish or such a small tank.
 
Bderick67;3250991; said:
You don't know how to tell if someone is banned or not?

Why would he banned anyhow? :duh:

Rhetorical question. And I ask because like other people who ask advice on such outrageous combinations (like TheBestPacuKeeper or whatever) generally end up banned.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com