Yellow Bullhead Catfish

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
2004exrider;2044233; said:
Cool your jets :chillpill: It wasn't an attack but an honest suggestion. Just because your bullhead didnt look unhappy doesnt mean he was healthy. Living in such a small environment is what killed him. He was stunted due to high Nitrates and more than likely ammonia and nitrites too (assuming your filtrtion couldnt handle the bio load). You need a bigger tank (for a bigger fish, not the small ones you have now) to help dillute the nitrates so you water stays cleaner longer otherwise they'll build up a lot faster. Also "mommy and daddy" havent bought anything for me, my whole life ive worked for everything i own just as i assume you do. All i was stating was that if you're gonna keep a bigger fish at least properly house it. And welcome to MFK, if you keep an open mind you will learn a lot of valuable information here.:)

Jimmy

what part of first Wild fish I owned and had live do you not understand? Never said it was best conditions nor was it the worst.
Its idiots like you that make clubing baby seals look fun.
 
Warf-12;2044312; said:
No ****, what part of first Wild fish I owned and had live do you not understand? Never said it was best conditions nor was it the worst.
Its idiots like you that make clubing baby seals look fun.

Wow, you're really off to a great start here.:screwy: You come to a forum and get a little advice then freak out and show how ignorant and immature you are. Second, sending me the message "Collective minds have decided you're an idiot, please crawl into a whole with filthy disease ridden badgers and die." I think you meant to say "hole" but thanks for the advice:ROFL:

Jimmy
 
There is no need to attack people giving out advice, warf.

The fish you have should reach around a foot when fully grown and they should be supplied with more swimming room and better water quality then you can deliver for that large of fish in a 20 gallon tank.

However, 7 years is actually rather close to how long bullheads generally live for, but I think thats more a testament to their extreme toughness, heck these are the fish that stay alive for days while hooked through the back on a set-line.

Now back to the bad. If you can't properly house the fish, I wouldn't recommend keeping the fish, even if it does live out a full life, it can't possibly be happy stuck in a tank just as wide as it should be long and around twice as long as it.

People on MFK can't force you to do anything, but if you keep up with keeping fish this way you are going to get told a lot that you are incredibly overstocked and the fish you keep are going to be unhappy. And thats no reason for you to attack people trying to help. If you choose to come onto this forum and participate, then you also choose to receive opinions from other members.
 
you sound like an idiot warf. mommy and daddy dont us everything we want. most of us are older than small children. why would you come to this site for advice and then attack the people that give you the CORRECT advice. dont keep large fish in a 20g tank.

and how many wild fish do you take home and have die? you said that bullhead was the first one that lived. maybe cuz you force them to live in a glass jar
 
Warf-12;2044312; said:
No ****, what part of first Wild fish I owned and had live do you not understand? Never said it was best conditions nor was it the worst.
Its idiots like you that make clubing baby seals look fun.
can you please settle down? you're making yourself look like an absolute tool. just take the GOOD advice you've been given, and stop being so rude and immature.
 
mine has grown an inch since thanksgiving, (when i got it)
 
X24;2046789; said:
There is no need to attack people giving out advice, warf.

The fish you have should reach around a foot when fully grown and they should be supplied with more swimming room and better water quality then you can deliver for that large of fish in a 20 gallon tank.

However, 7 years is actually rather close to how long bullheads generally live for, but I think thats more a testament to their extreme toughness, heck these are the fish that stay alive for days while hooked through the back on a set-line.

Now back to the bad. If you can't properly house the fish, I wouldn't recommend keeping the fish, even if it does live out a full life, it can't possibly be happy stuck in a tank just as wide as it should be long and around twice as long as it.

People on MFK can't force you to do anything, but if you keep up with keeping fish this way you are going to get told a lot that you are incredibly overstocked and the fish you keep are going to be unhappy. And thats no reason for you to attack people trying to help. If you choose to come onto this forum and participate, then you also choose to receive opinions from other members.

Do you have a source for the age a bullhead can achieve?I would have guessed at least 15 maybe 20. My cardinal tetras live to be 5 or 6 routinely, a bullhead should live a lot longer than that.
 
Moontanman;2052697; said:
Do you have a source for the age a bullhead can achieve?I would have guessed at least 15 maybe 20. My cardinal tetras live to be 5 or 6 routinely, a bullhead should live a lot longer than that.

http://www.tpwd.state.tx.us/huntwild/wild/species/bigfish/
http://www.michigan.gov/dnr/0,1607,7-153-10364_18958-45648--,00.html
http://www.rook.org/earl/bwca/nature/fish/ictalurusneb.html
http://www.outdooralabama.com/fishing/freshwater/fish/catfish/bullhead/black/

I'm convinced you are either lying (most probable), don't have a yellow bullhead (if you aren't lying then you don't), are getting your bullhead species confused (again, very likely to happen). Most likely its a combination of these three though.

Yellow bullheads don't get 18" and i seriously doubt any bullhead lived 7 years and got to 18" in your 20 gallon tank. That would me it not be able to turn around and it must have taken up around half the tank :ROFL:

Black and brown bullhead rarely ever get close to 18", the 18"ers are RECORDS, not normal.

My honest opinion, complete BS.
 
X24;2052781; said:
http://www.tpwd.state.tx.us/huntwild/wild/species/bigfish/
http://www.michigan.gov/dnr/0,1607,7-153-10364_18958-45648--,00.html
http://www.rook.org/earl/bwca/nature/fish/ictalurusneb.html
http://www.outdooralabama.com/fishing/freshwater/fish/catfish/bullhead/black/

I'm convinced you are either lying (most probable), don't have a yellow bullhead (if you aren't lying then you don't), are getting your bullhead species confused (again, very likely to happen). Most likely its a combination of these three though.

Yellow bullheads don't get 18" and i seriously doubt any bullhead lived 7 years and got to 18" in your 20 gallon tank. That would me it not be able to turn around and it must have taken up around half the tank :ROFL:

Black and brown bullhead rarely ever get close to 18", the 18"ers are RECORDS, not normal.

My honest opinion, complete BS.

I'm going to assume you weren't talking to me when you said I was a lier but I agree it's unlikely a yellow bullhead got to be 18" in a 20 gallon tank or any tank for that matter. I wonder if the ages on the links you provided are wild fish or captive fish? Cardinals only live to be a little over a year in the wild, five years plus in captivity. Some people do have problems measuring their own fish, particularly when they catch them on hook and line. Maybe fish in a tank inspire the same artistic license:naughty:
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com