Yes or No: succesfully kept jardini with tankmates.

[johnptc]

yes but in a very large tank

 

[krichardson]

No,my jar got along quite nicely with my vittatus tiger untill he got tired of the tiger and killed it.

 

[Hao]

No,my jar got along quite nicely with my vittatus tiger untill he got tired of the tiger and killed it.

sucks lol

 

[ctoychik]

thats interesting. every asian i have worked out in a comm. i guess jardinis dont like me very much.

my jar is living peacefully with 3 silver and a green aros and ray (bichir was moved out with asians).

my comm tank of asian aros was (is) a disaster.

 

[blazin_dragon18]

u should realli define the length of the fish in this poll...i bet most of the ppl who said yes have small aro, under 13" or so...cuz their temper man...they grow w/their length lol
also, depends on the tank mates. if it's not the dominant fish in the tank, i think that mite work

 

[pwmin]

You should also ask at what size they killed their first if they're not compatible.

So far, at 12", mine is tolerant of most tankmates.

 

[jbnebres]

yes but in a very large tank

i concur.
i don't know about anyone else, but i am growing my tiny jar with two rotkeils in a 75g for the mean time. imagine if it had the ample room- say 220+. with that much room, the chances for cohabitation are more likely.
The success rate for a community with a jardini, is not only influenced by it's innate aggressive nature, but also the direct proportionate size of it's housing.

so maybe there's more math to figure out, in terms of success rate x size of tank, but if one is seriously trying to house jardinis with other fish, better get your wallets out.

now to get that 220...

 

[Laosy Fish]

I just picked up a Jar and his tankmates had to have an emrgency evac. so my vote is no...

 

[Laosy Fish]

he's about 12"-13" and is in a 150g wide tank all by himself now.

 

[Fishes33]

its a NO

Baby jar pick fight with a slightly bigger baby green

and got himself punked >.>;;