TANKED on Animal Planet

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
When I watched them build the cross for the church tank out of cheap pressboard I wasn't too impressed - couldn't they have used synthetic lumber or at least marine plywood? The fact that the ugly-as-sin piece of junk wouldn't sink makes them look ignorant and incompetent. I won't be tuning in again any time soon...

I knew from the start thier was air in it, especially if you add objects like shells and plastic decorations upside down into the tanks. I'm pretty sure they knew what they were doing...but for it's just TV and thats it...it was made to give the viewers the thought of "Oh Know, what will they do"....just to keep viewrs on thier toes and interested to stay tune. Remember it is heavily heavily edited and scripted.....if you have not yet, you should view the link posted by zoodiver from above....Brett even explains its mainly for the non-hobbist....and he even relates it to shows featured on animal planet like river monsters and whale wars.
 
The church aquarium makes me sick to my stomach. The pasture says every church should at least have a fish bowl? Really? Really??? The money spent on that massive tank could have saved a lot of lives of people who are starving but nope, we gotta use it to send a message with a massive tank. That's a sick joke. The show itself on the other hand sounds totally scripted but it's silly, it's pretty fun to watch, I like it. I understand it's TV but I wish they'd give a tad more accurate info on how to care for fish and set up tanks. I guarantee a decent number of the people who come in to the shop I work at are somewhat mislead from the get go from shows like this.

Just a friendly reminded: Keep the religious comments to ourselves (as per site rules).




PASTURE is where you keep cows, sheep, goats and horses. A PASTOR is the leader of a church. Getting your words right gives you a better foot to stand on when talking about others.

I don't think it's waste of money, it's being used as a teaching tool. If that is a waste, let's end the pet trade all together and zoos and aqauriums as well. Think of all the people we could save if we spent our fish money on the homeless. Shoe doesn't fit the other foot too well does it?

bravo response.

Just a thought. Regardless of whether it be a church, business (atm) or whatever. Until I am the one who controls the books for said operation I will not tell them how they should do things.

Personally I think the church tank rocked. Way to go monster!!!!!!!
 
Just a friendly reminded: Keep the religious comments to ourselves (as per site rules).




PASTURE is where you keep cows, sheep, goats and horses. A PASTOR is the leader of a church. Getting your words right gives you a better foot to stand on when talking about others.

I don't think it's waste of money, it's being used as a teaching tool. If that is a waste, let's end the pet trade all together and zoos and aqauriums as well. Think of all the people we could save if we spent our fish money on the homeless. Shoe doesn't fit the other foot too well does it?

Not to focus on the religion part, but I just tend to think that any organization that acts as a charity, probably shouldn't be spending their funds on an extravagent fish tank. I know if I gave to the Red Cross for disaster relief, and found out they spent the money on a petting zoo, I wouldn't be too pleased. It's one thing if there were a capital campaign dedicated solely to raising for funds for this, but if I were giving money to a cause and found out it was used on something this extravagent, I would think twice about giving my money again.
 
R you on their board? Were you there when the vision for the new building was given?

Matters little what they are, matters much if you are not in the know as to what things were put forth for people to make the decision to support the building of this. I am pretty sure the fiducary trust nature of monies given for this project were spent to do exactly what they were raised for.

So far as I understand it was very clear that this monster tank was very much out in the open for everyone to know what they were supporting and giving to considering the building was built around the fish tank and took 2 years to complete.

Not to focus on the religion part, but I just tend to think that any organization that acts as a charity, probably shouldn't be spending their funds on an extravagent fish tank. I know if I gave to the Red Cross for disaster relief, and found out they spent the money on a petting zoo, I wouldn't be too pleased. It's one thing if there were a capital campaign dedicated solely to raising for funds for this, but if I were giving money to a cause and found out it was used on something this extravagent, I would think twice about giving my money again.
 
definitely a good show and to all the picky ones out there that complain about not cycling and them not knowing there stuff im pretty sure they would have a tv show and say they are the largest acrylic tank manufacturer in the world for no reason. they know what they are talking about and take trips to hand pick out the fish for their tanks and i never cycle any of my tanks but i do a ton of water changes when i set them up as to make up for the cycle not starting yet
 
Looking at the church as a business for a minute, that church raised funds to build the new church with the tank as part of it from the beginning. The people who gave their money to build it knew what it was going for. It wasn't money that was raised to go to something else.
And before anyone asks, yes - I was there. They guy who headed up the filtration for that tank also worked with me to do the touch pool filtration here in Miami.
 
Im Personally Not impressed with the show. they always use coral inserts, never properly cycle the tank, and half the time they overcrowd the tank, if i was paying someone that much money to build me a tank i personally would expect much ,much more. plus im a freshwater guy and they always do Saltwater
 
When I watched them build the cross for the church tank out of cheap pressboard I wasn't too impressed - couldn't they have used synthetic lumber or at least marine plywood? The fact that the ugly-as-sin piece of junk wouldn't sink makes them look ignorant and incompetent. I won't be tuning in again any time soon...

If you watch the show closely, in the scene where they are messing with cross it is bright daylight outside and there is almost no one in the room (you can see it in the reflection a couple of times) yet when they are doing the unveiling the room is packed and it is nearly dark outside. It was made for TV drama, that's all.

If you take the show for what it's worth, a cheesy reality show that also involves aquariums and fish, it's not that bad. At least in my opinion.
 
If you watch the show closely, in the scene where they are messing with cross it is bright daylight outside and there is almost no one in the room (you can see it in the reflection a couple of times) yet when they are doing the unveiling the room is packed and it is nearly dark outside. It was made for TV drama, that's all.

If you take the show for what it's worth, a cheesy reality show that also involves aquariums and fish, it's not that bad. At least in my opinion.

I understand that the floating cross fiasco was just for drama, I still think it made them appear like bumbling fools.

The construction of the cross was the part that really disappointed me. Using waferboard for the base is ridiculous - I wonder if the cross is only temporary? This kind of product is full of formaldehyde and antimicrobial agents, definitely not something you should be putting in an aquarium, even for a short time.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com