Who would you keep?/Who would you remove?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Personally I think the Argentea will be tight, a friend of mine has a 15 inch male, doable but tight.
If you want 1 fish the midas will likely be the most fun once he grows, polleni are cool too though so I'm guessing bleekeri would be very similar and like an oscar as my polleni was...
I would do midas, the jd is a female so could probably stay with the midas if it's male.
i just noticed your sig says "project umvii" haha. thats a good one.
 
Lol, I don't expect it too work but yes I'm planning on devoting my 300 to this!-)
 
Would be like a military vehicle right!-)
 
Long term, no. Forget about them getting along... A 75 gallons is too small for those two.
And if the argentea is already showing off he's the boss in a tank with several fish, that will only escalate once you reduce the amount of fish in there.
 
I have personally kept all of these fish before except the bleekeri, but am familiar with it.

The argentea are stunning, less common, and get a lot of attention, but are sneaky fin nippers when kept with other fish. Mine would constantly pick at fish even twice his size growing up and was skittish if he was alone though. Bleekeri and midas would have the most confidence and character when kept solo probably.

I wouldnt pick just one, I'd try to keep the JD with the bleekeri or the red devil. Whichever gets along better. Short term though. .. get the argentea out in his own tank temporarily. More fish will die soon.
 
I have personally kept all of these fish before except the bleekeri, but am familiar with it.

The argentea are stunning, less common, and get a lot of attention, but are sneaky fin nippers when kept with other fish. Mine would constantly pick at fish even twice his size growing up and was skittish if he was alone though. Bleekeri and midas would have the most confidence and character when kept solo probably.

I wouldnt pick just one, I'd try to keep the JD with the bleekeri or the red devil. Whichever gets along better. Short term though. .. get the argentea out in his own tank temporarily. More fish will die soon.

Sorry u said it was a midas not a red devil. My bad.
 
Could the vieja share the 75 gal tank with the bleekeri? Has anyone seen these fish live together?





Keep the Argentea Only Nothing else will grow much with him, so in the end it's gonna be just the Argentea and or you can keep the Polleni too but need lots of hiding places and it wont grow much.
 
Keep the Argentea Only Nothing else will grow much with him, so in the end it's gonna be just the Argentea and or you can keep the Polleni too but need lots of hiding places and it wont grow much.
is that yours?
 
Oh you saw it. yeah it WAS mine.Then I sold him to Robert in Anaheim.He's a mellow fish.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com