Switched from prime to safe- dead fish

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
" he knows because he has a PhD" . in my world comments such as that put you on an immediate ignore list.

Funny stuff, Carp being admin on his own little site. Doc fish was referring to a slow rate drip system, although I have no idea why we are discussing that now? Maybe start your own thread Carp, and you and your new best friend can have it instead of adding zero value to this discussion.
 
I am not saying because he has a phd, he knows because he has a huge fish house and has a lot of fishkeeping experience. There is a thread on my site about the drip system. What is so funny about my site?
 
Sorry Wiksta, this is where I get off. Good luck buddy, sorry that you lost some fish, and hopefully it never happens again. I experienced the same thing 15 years or so back, I simply blamed my wife and moved on. :)
 
Sorry Wiksta, this is where I get off. Good luck buddy, sorry that you lost some fish, and hopefully it never happens again. I experienced the same thing 15 years or so back, I simply blamed my wife and moved on. :)

Lol, thanks for your advice RD. I do appreciate the debate. It's always good to learn more information. Ill let you know how the next round of water changes go.
 
Sounds good, maybe just send me a PM. lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wiksta
It isn't hard and boring. I don't have a lasting impression of bad fish husbandry. I have heard of people with saltwater tanks that haven't done water changes in years. I am not that bad lol.

If you really think that people with saltwater tanks don't do water changes because they are lazy then I don't think you have any business trying to post any fish-keeping advice to anyone. Saltwater tanks are entirely different animals than freshwater. Because of the specific gravity and salinity, they are able to use entirely different equipment than freshwater tanks.

For example, freshwater tanks do water changes, mainly to remove nitrates, remove TDS, remineralize the water (yes, fish need minerals in the water), and to help reoxygenate the water. There are very few success stories for anyone using stuff on a freshwater tank to take care of these items, other than surface agitation and air stones for oxygenation.

However, on a saltwater tank, they can use macroalgae and deep sand beds to remove nitrates, a protein skimmer to remove TDS, dosing to remineralize the water, and surface agitation/air stones to reoxygenate the water. Therefore, if a tank is set up properly, it does not need water changes. It is actually a testimant to the fish keepers ability to keep their tank so well balanced that it is possible to not do water changes. It is not easy to do as I'm sure many would tell you.

As far as the comments about bad husbandry, you brought that on yourself. You have several threads that YOU started regarding your lost interest in this hobby, "not feeling like doing water changes", and having let your tanks "go too long without water changes." If you want to get rid of that reputation then I suggest you work hard at maintaining your tanks and keeping them in top condition/health.
 
If you really think that people with saltwater tanks don't do water changes because they are lazy then I don't think you have any business trying to post any fish-keeping advice to anyone.
It was a joke -_-

I have been maintaining my tanks. I just worry about me losing interest, even when my tanks are in great condition. My 20 gallon tank crashed a while ago https://www.I Will Not Spam on MFK.us/threads/2-of-my-guppies-got-sucked-into-the-filter.268. I worry about a lot of stuff.
 
my thoughts exactly. I was ready to read all of this debate with the utmost care so as to learn something useful....then Mr. Water-changes-are-hard rolled in and threw his two cents into one corner and I immediately stopped caring lol.
I was wondering why this thread was going so long and I finally gave in and took a look,LOL!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com