I was thinking that some rope fish might be nice to Hendre's tank... do you think that "counts" when it comes to polys?
I don't know, Polyaddict. I have read recommendations of the same by you and a couple of others. But at the same time most of the people recommending that have like 8 or 18 polys LOL. It's not that I don't trust you, and I certainly don't have much Poly experience, but many fish "rules" outside of tank size are just cautionary guidelines.
Kind of like with Bettas - people always ask: can they live with other fish or shrimp? Some would say no, not worth trying. Others would say it depends on the fish - you have to try it and be ready to quickly go to plan B should things change. I've had multiple Bettas that could live with other fish, 2 that could live with shrimp, and my current one can only live with a snail.
-I think individual fish temperament is huge.
-I do appreciate Hendre not wanting to overstock, yet wanting more polys.
-I don't see the harm in trying to add one more and see how it goes.... if it doesn't work he decides whether to add more or rehome one fish.
Like I said, my Palmas was such a jerk I really don't know if having one more fish, with a count of 3 total, would have fixed the situation.
Curious to hear what others think and their experiences either way.