Strange snails out of no where???

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
So these snails in my tank aren't harmful to my tank or pose a threat to things in my tank? I mean if they are beneficial I might let them hang out for a little while I guess. But longterm to wipe em out would be lettuce and a loach from what I'm gathering. The only thing is with the loach I'd be afraid my gar would take a dabble and my ornate polypterus would probably as well

Some snails hitched a ride into my tank on some live plants several years ago even through I was pretty thorough about cleaning the plants with peroxide. I was a little ticked at first. After a few months the snail propagated quite a bit and I started noticing a complete lack of any algae. It didn't take long to really appreciate the algae free tank and the snails that were doing all the work. The snails I have are so small I don't really notice them unless I look for them.
 
Hmmm snails to fight off snails. Do these assassin snails get a little crazy to as far as population?
No, the good thing about assassin snails is that they don't breed fast, they breed rather slow if my memory is correct however I have not bred them and am merely repeating my findings from various threads online.

" fishhead0103666 fishhead0103666
Im going to have to be quicker on this typing!
you beat me again! Lol" Typically the tortoise beats the rabbit but for now it has been reversed.
 
Post some pics so we can help you ID them. Generally most aquarium snails aren't going to cause you any problems and will only populate to the level of food available. I have five species of snails.
I have different mixes of them in almost every tank, and I have never seen any detrimental effects from them. I've learned to appreciate them more and more as I use more plants in my tanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twentyleagues
I have live bearing snails in most of my tanks but I also have loaches and pea puffers. I’m guaranteed a food source for the puffers. I just moved my three smallest puffers into my 29g cherry shrimp tank and am hoping they don’t prey heavily on the shrimps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PredatorPiqued
Many cichlids eat snails. I collected the plants in Lake Gatun for my present tank, and many snails rode along, but after a year there aren't any left, the cichlids (Andinoacara coeleopunctatus) wiped them out,
My favorite snail eating cichlids are the Paretroplus from Madagascar. If a tank became too overrun with snails, I'd move in a Paretroplus maculatus and within 24 hours the tank would be almost snail free.
They could crush small snails, but for large solid shelled ones they'd use their "can opener" like teeth to yank out the flesh.
 
My favorite snail eating cichlids are the Paretroplus from Madagascar. If a tank became too overrun with snails, I'd move in a Paretroplus maculatus and within 24 hours the tank would be almost snail free.
They could crush small snails, but for large solid shelled ones they'd use their "can opener" like teeth to yank out the flesh.
One caveat to this, don't get this species (or most other Paretroplus) unless your tank is over 6ft long.
P. kieneri is the only one that fits smaller tanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
My experience with clown loaches is that they will eat some snails (Physa, Planorbis, Gyraulus, Helisoma) but they will not touch Malaysian trumpet snails. I don't know why. Others' experiences may differ.
 
Hey guys so I was able to grab a few pictures this morning, I apologize for my low camera quality.
But if I could describe with my own eyes would be, they have swirly like shell coming to a point, with tan and brown markings

20200507_103918.jpg

20200507_103804.jpg

20200507_103649.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: BIG-G
MonsterFishKeepers.com