My Silver Dollar Sp's

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Hopefully others can chime in with help. I don't have a clue what is going one with that female fish. I have not seen that type of blotches before. It appears that her behavior is normal?
In the image, the blotches appear darker than the silvery fish. However, earlier I thought I understood the blotches were lighter color (whitish?) In other words, have the blotches changed color? The earlier picture where you added circles around some blotches appeared to have a white circle around the discolored area; however, that is not clearly seen in the most recent picture. I am unsure if the blotching is a concern or not.
Although if it is something bad, whatever it is is likely in the entire tank (that individual fish is not a new introduction, and there have not been other introductions). The fact that as you state the issue is with that single fish, could be a red flag, but I am unsure of what.
What I would do is continue to monitor, and maintain excellent water quality. I would solve the situation with the unusual parameter readings (make sure to test the actual test kit, such as with distilled water) so you now it is working properly. I would expect anythin wrong with water parameters to affect multiple fish (even if not equally), not just the one.
If it gets worse on the individual fish (and does not appears on others), and her behavior changesI would separate her. But if everything seems normal (except the blotching), then I would not separate her. I just don't think she will do ok by herself in a tank, specially if there is no clear treatment to follow.
Good luck!
 
Hopefully others can chime in with help. I don't have a clue what is going one with that female fish. I have not seen that type of blotches before. It appears that her behavior is normal?
In the image, the blotches appear darker than the silvery fish. However, earlier I thought I understood the blotches were lighter color (whitish?) In other words, have the blotches changed color? The earlier picture where you added circles around some blotches appeared to have a white circle around the discolored area; however, that is not clearly seen in the most recent picture. I am unsure if the blotching is a concern or not.
Although if it is something bad, whatever it is is likely in the entire tank (that individual fish is not a new introduction, and there have not been other introductions). The fact that as you state the issue is with that single fish, could be a red flag, but I am unsure of what.
What I would do is continue to monitor, and maintain excellent water quality. I would solve the situation with the unusual parameter readings (make sure to test the actual test kit, such as with distilled water) so you now it is working properly. I would expect anythin wrong with water parameters to affect multiple fish (even if not equally), not just the one.
If it gets worse on the individual fish (and does not appears on others), and her behavior changesI would separate her. But if everything seems normal (except the blotching), then I would not separate her. I just don't think she will do ok by herself in a tank, specially if there is no clear treatment to follow.
Good luck!

Yes, there were some white blemishes beginning around 23NOV20. There is only one of those that looked like a potential injury. There were several darker blemishes as well with the condition progressing to the present blemishes all over the one fish. I have a 29g with some guppys I can move her to for isolation treatment (cost savings on medication really).
I will test water again today.
Would a slime coat additive possibly help? I use Seachem Safe on this tank.
 
Added 5 silver dollar size Metynnis Hypsauchen the 120g. Origin is the Wet Spot by way of @Ruturaj. Still settling in but look good and nothing tone won’t heal. I have an adult in the 220g that I will move after lights out.
8C0D7692-2D5A-4621-A139-1B952298CC81.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: DMD123
1A911C55-25C3-456B-8711-EC1230A04F28.jpeg7292FF8F-9860-451B-BEBB-94D937FDD53F.jpeg5BC5ACD7-11ED-47E0-9055-9A00495C9CA8.jpeg0C927A78-3D55-4AD5-826D-6577BBE82B49.jpeg4E2570D9-EF68-45D7-BAAF-B967F30B46B5.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: DMD123
The blotchy one is still the same. It hasn’t been eating. I tried nori sheets and none of the SD touched them when normally they are devouring it.
Newbs with the transfered adult:
64ECD297-2C34-4B63-9D22-0C280E8FB64C.jpegD1AB7487-01EC-42C1-B284-050F7807D6AE.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: DMD123
I just turned the lights on quick to snag some pictures while everyone was groggy.
7582B54B-E724-437C-B3B9-270E113ED21D.jpegD3431707-2381-47FC-94AC-CF36C64666BB.jpeg
Trailing SD above is leading SD below
0DA6010E-50DD-4041-B404-01F4C8D8E899.jpegBA42E9F7-6AE2-43C3-B055-311E1FEEAA14.jpeg
For size tank is 4ft x 2ft
FF13666D-E168-469F-B882-F0677E8BEA05.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matteus and DMD123
Very nice, thanks!
Look forward to seeing how they grow and develop.
I hope the blotchy fish improves.
One item I give my fish (as candy, part of of a long list of rotating items) is garbanzos. Right from the can - I remove from can rinse well several times (to remove all can juices), and mash a little with fingers into the tank. Freeze the rest; I use them once a week.
My SD's cannot resist them! The nutritional value may not be high (they get many other higher nutrition items), but it certainly gets them wild and into eating anything that goes in. May want to try it. I would try one garbanzo & see what the fish does, one more if it is eaten.
Good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: fishguy1978
My new 5 Dollars are wild caught :woot:
Looks like he is healing up. Not eating though
71C54FCE-1CA9-4F0E-BF24-934DA80B332D.jpeg1CA627E6-7BC6-490C-B470-8D9DDF60846D.jpeg
 
Blotchy is looking much better. I ordered some API water conditioner with stress coat to use on the SD since they are so sensitive. Did a 40% water change and added the new stuff. Hopefully his appetite comes back. Tried the nori again and nobody touched it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
MonsterFishKeepers.com