Alternatives to Pothos

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I use multiple varieties of pothos, tradescantia zebrina, tradescantia fluminensis, tradescantia pallida, and I'm going to be trying guynura aurantiaca or purple velvet.

View attachment 1446258
oh man!

what are your nitrates here? how often w/c?

great looking!
 
oh man!

what are your nitrates here? how often w/c?

great looking!
Thank you! Just responded to that question from someone else above. Must have been typing at the same time. The plants do grow quickly with a dedicated light on them, and have to be trimmed and reset periodically. I've come to rely on natural methods more and more after getting into planted tanks. Some fish just wont allow plants but this method has worked well for me. Haven't had any species mess with the roots at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dr exum
I have two tanks like this. Nitrates never even register with a standard water change routine. I used to do 50% a week, but over time I've cut it back to 30% every other week. The plants have been cut way back multiple times but always grow back. Also just fish in this one, all manner of cichlids have been grown out in here. The other tank is mutt guppies, shrimp, and snails. That tank is a constant zero for nitrates, and I go much longer in between water changes. Maybe 25% once a month.

That is some impressive nitrate reduction. Something like this will possibly be my next project on my 180g.

1. How are the individual plants anchored?
2. Are they each in little pots allowing the roots to creep out of the bottom into the water?
3. Do you use any type of gravel or soil for the plants?
4. How the hell do you vacuum your gravel?
5. Can they be individually removed or, by now, are they just one huge interminged plant that you just trim once in a while?
 
I just hang plants around the rim, and some time place a piece bamboo across the width to help.
They don't need soil or substrate.
A3428095-CE4D-449A-8891-0C85F66933B1_1_201_a.jpeg

The roots simply dangle in the water, I like the natural look, and fish seem to appreciate the cover.
501E33E2-6AB1-4A71-9273-F70F9D7DE590_1_201_a.jpeg
750A0CB2-5FBD-4EBB-A381-91F14A841779_1_201_a.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Terrestrial plants with their feet in the water are great for consuming nitrogenous waste. My latest fishroom is a finished garage with skylights (and windows) so there's enough light in some places to grow papyrus plants... I also have Pothos, several varieties of Philodendrons, Peace Lilly , wandering jew and Bolivian jew. There's a great nursery locally that has a houseplant hobbyist who propagates all sorts of tropical plants for sale in their store for a few bucks each. Between the ones I've bought and the ones I've propagated myself I've got plants in most tanks and/or their overhead filters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Thank you! Just responded to that question from someone else above. Must have been typing at the same time. The plants do grow quickly with a dedicated light on them, and have to be trimmed and reset periodically. I've come to rely on natural methods more and more after getting into planted tanks. Some fish just wont allow plants but this method has worked well for me. Haven't had any species mess with the roots at all.

How does the total dissolved solid levels compare to your tap/source water? Is it lower, by how much? Is it higher, by how much?
 
I tried them a couple of times but they never worked for me, They turn yellow and die for some reason
 
That is some impressive nitrate reduction. Something like this will possibly be my next project on my 180g.

1. How are the individual plants anchored?
2. Are they each in little pots allowing the roots to creep out of the bottom into the water?
3. Do you use any type of gravel or soil for the plants?
4. How the hell do you vacuum your gravel?
5. Can they be individually removed or, by now, are they just one huge interminged plant that you just trim once in a while?
No fertilizer, or pots. Just plant cuttings in water. I have a standard aqueon versa top, and I use a hole saw that's about one inch to cut circular holes all along the plastic strip at the back. It's as simple as that. The plants do grow into a tangled mass, but I can actually open the lids push the slim light back, and lift the plants to sort of use them to keep the tops open if that makes sense.
Also they aren't always this overgrown.
Here is a different pic that doesnt have as much growth. The fish like the roots for cover.

20201016_160539.jpg

IMG_20201030_164940_771.jpg

IMG_20201125_160033_148.jpg

IMG_20201125_153613_308.jpg
 
I tried them a couple of times but they never worked for me, They turn yellow and die for some reason

Pothos?

They take awhile for all the terrestrial roots to convert into aquatic roots. The plant won't look or do great during that transition. I've had pothos growing out of a large marina brand breeder box off the back of my oscar tank for years. The kind of breeder box that uses bubbles and an air pump to pump water in/out of. I used to have the pothos winding around the room, but that kind of makes a mess of painted drywall walls, plus I've found sometimes the vines weep water, so you have to be mindful of that.
 
How does the total dissolved solid levels compare to your tap/source water? Is it lower, by how much? Is it higher, by how much?


I don't measure for TDS, even in my shrimp tanks. Just regular tap water. I haven't used ferts in over a year, although I do need to start fertilizing my planted tanks again. Definitely starting to notice them slow down.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com