Agressive Peacock? Not sure what to do??

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

JayK1320

Candiru
MFK Member
Feb 22, 2008
501
11
48
42
Boston, MA
So I have got two male peacocks of the same variety, I believe they are both Ruby Red. They obviously do not get along and one is getting harassed pretty bad, so the choice is obvious one has to go...

This leads to the real questions, which should I keep?

The one being harassed is actually the larger of the two by at least a 1/2" maybe an 1". I would say total he is 4-4.5", he is obviously the less aggressive of the two, but along with that he seems to be less colorful. Obviously he is stressed from being picked on constantly, so I cant expect him to be in full show.

The smaller one has to be 3-3.5" and is really good looking, much more spectacular than the smaller one, showing lost of blue in the face, a nice red/orange in the body, always showing off. I really like this fish, but my concern is his aggression, could that be a sign of more to come as he gets larger?

I have another Peacock male that I am thinking is a Red Shoulder, so he is mostly blue and showing a little red in the shoulder obviously. This is a #1 fish, had this guy the longest since he was tiny and I just love it, he is the fish I like the most and the one people are most impressed with. So I am worried that the Red that I like a lot to could one day decide he wants no other males in the tank and start picking on the blue? I know every fish is different and some are more aggressive and some are more subtle. But, with peacocks specifically is it common if one is feeling like he can rule the roost he wont let anything swim around? That is not what I want, I want a pretty community tank of all peacocks.

So I am looking for advice on what to do? Keep the smaller one and hope it doesnt get to aggressive, or am I in for a king of the hill 24/7 with all the fish in the tank with this guy? Or do I keep the obviously weaker fish and hope that his colors would pop once the aggressor is taken out of the tank? I have a 10g setup with fry in it right now, I could put the agressive one in there for awhile and see what happens. If I was to do this how long should I leave him in there for to give the weaker fish a chance to perk up?

Like I said, my goal here is to have free swimming happy fish, not one king tut kicking the crap out of any other male trying to get with his females.
 
How large is your tank? You could probably add another male in that group and help disperse the aggression, or you could remove the victimized male. Just because you remove the aggressive male doesn't mean you remove the aggression in your tank. I have a group of otter point jacos and there's a sub dominant male that does get picked on, but he's still perfectly fine health wise. It's just a natural part of their behavior. I would only be concerned if he wasn't eating or something... then you have a problem.

Keep your: favorite fish > most colorful fish > best breeders > everyone else... At least in my opinion :). Good luck!
 
mike dunagan;2181536; said:
Can you take the lesser male out and see what he looks like colored up in a lone tank. Then if he looks better keep him.

That is what I was thinking too, my only other tank is a 10g I have set up with a bunch of fry in it...so I guess I will just have to pass them on for the greater good. I was considering taking the aggressive male out of the big tank to see how things worked out.

Which would be better to do? Isolate the aggressor or the weaker one? Then how long should I give it to feel comfortable and let his coloring come out?
 
isolate the weak one.. see if he colors up nice without the other one beating him down..
 
navygirl76;2181882; said:
isolate the weak one.. see if he colors up nice without the other one beating him down..

How long should this take? Is it like a few hours or a few days? I will pull him out as soon as I get home...should be like 15 minutes from now :D
 
If it was up to me id pull out the aggressor #1 because hes smaller, #2 because if you introduce the less aggressive one back into the tank with the aggressor, the aggressor will feel like the weaker one is coming into his terroritory, when if you introduce the aggressor back into the tank he won't be as aggressive to try to "defend" his territory, thats imo
 
I would pull the weaker, wait a week... see who has better color and that one. If you pull the aggressive one, the less may still not show the color since other fish in the tank are still more aggressive... if you like the color of the weaker one better, you will be removing the more aggressive if you reintroduce it...
 
If you remove the weaker of the two you will never be able to put it back into the tank with the more dominant male still in there. Thats not my opinion, thats basically fact. Try rearranging the tank so that they can reestablish territories, maybe that will help.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com