ewurm;2954759; said:
It just depends on what you consider a "right". As far as the 2nd amendment ic concerned, I don't see any difference in what they called "arms". You could be talking about a musket or an M60. They didn't know the differnce. You could argue that the M60 is something you have the "right" to own under the 2nd amendment, but you would probably consider that ridiculous. I don't see an AR-15 falling under the 2nd amendment either. I see that falling under the discretionary judgement of the people. You can't read the 2nd amendment the way you see fit. In their day it's muskets or nothing. In ours it's the M249 SAW or nothing, if that's the way you want to read it. Everything else is discretionary. It's not a "right", it's a "responsibily". If the people that own these weapons are responsible and can generate a good argument for having them, they will be allowed to do so. If the argument is "rights" and "safety", then we wont have the right to own them.
Well, I believe the constitution should be read exactly how it's written. Arms = guns (not weapons), do I think someone should own a bomb? Of course not, it's not an arm it's a destructive device. but I would suggest that any law abiding citizen should be able to own whatever gun they see fit.
What other reason do we have other than it's our right, as born American citizens, as defined in the Constitution, to own a .22, .30-06, .357 magnum, .50 BMG, or even a M249 SAW. The only reason I can think of, especially for the M249 would be simply for fun.
I certainly agree that background checks should be done. I guess my question to you is if a person is a law abiding citizen, what right do you have to deny him the firearm he wants?
Like I said, law abiding citizens, don't give you any reason to fear. They don't commit crimes, and they enjoy their guns.
I don't see it as, "tell me why you want it and I'll tell you if you can have it.".
I see it as, "If you haven't done anything wrong, and that's what you want and you can afford it, go have a blast!"
Why do you prefer someone to explain to you why they want something simply to have it? This is a form of government control, and the very circumstance the constitution was created to eliminate. We are a free society.