anyone had this problem

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Hi Richard,

have read your post a few minutes ago for the first time and have had a look at your video.....

First: You are a really lucky guy, that your rays are still alive after your yet again esha treatment :eek:. Something in your tank must absorb copper, maybe your high carbonate hardness combined with your pH......esha is definitely not ray safe!! Please do a big water excange as soon as possible and never use esha again for your rays!

Your P14 are suffering from gill worms! The sometimes "gulping movements" during breathing heavy, which can be seen for a few times in the first part of your video, are typical. I would not wonder, if additionally they'd also breath onesided from time to time?

Raising temperature is contraproductive now!
Breathing is not easy for your rays after the massive increase of this gill parasiste, as you can easily see on your video (or by looking into your tank). Raising the temperature lowers the oxygene level in your water and makes everything worse! Tropical gill parasites are not impressed very much by the higher temperature. I'd go to 82-84.

Salt does not solve the problem here. It can help for a short time, cause the gills will release slime, but it wont solve the problem. I would not use it here, cause it'll also affect your filter bacteria!

Using a medicine with the active ingredient Praziquantel, will solve the heavy breathing problem within a few hours and I'd bet, that they'll all eat again within only 24 hours......if they are not damaged too much from your "additional treatments" :(

You can use Tremazol, but I'd prefer Wormex out of the koi sector, it's working much better.

Tremazol has to be used 2 or better 3 times within a certain interval, depending on the individual water temperature which regulates the developement of the gill worms eggs. Eggs cannot be affected by Praziquantel and you must get the hatched worms before laying eggs again.......or you will get the same probleme a few days/weeks/months later once again. Tremazol must be removed of the tank within 8-10 hours, because of the possible massive bacteria explosion (filter bacteria) and used again after the right time, which is difficult. Wormex can be left in the tank for at least 10 DAYS and within that time, it'll kill almost all worms, cause almost all worms hatch during 10 period of time. You'll never be able to gill all rays parasites, but you can kill as much, that the ray can handle the rest of them allone. As you can now for sure read between the lines, you do not have to have brought the parasites inside the tank now, they could also have been in the P14 since years and could break out because of stress, which P14 are very impressable for......I also had this problem for a few times within the last years....always after I tried to combine them with leopoldi ;) meanwhile I've given up to try that.

There is no need to hurry, lower the temperature, dont do any nonsens like esha or salt now and try to get the right medicine. Gill worm's won't kill your rays that quick.....the most dangerous this is the keepers impatience and fear. Dont forget to remove your cabon- and polyfilter when using medicine.

btw: I am sure about what I am telling you, believe me, I am a breeder and I'd have plenty of quarantaine tanks ;)

Regards
Stefan
 
StefanW;4222854; said:
Hi Richard,

have read your post a few minutes ago for the first time and have had a look at your video.....

First: You are a really lucky guy, that your rays are still alive after your yet again esha treatment :eek:. Something in your tank must absorb copper, maybe your high carbonate hardness combined with your pH......esha is definitely not ray safe!! Please do a big water excange as soon as possible and never use esha again for your rays!

Your P14 are suffering from gill worms! The sometimes "gulping movements" during breathing heavy, which can be seen for a few times in the first part of your video, are typical. I would not wonder, if additionally they'd also breath onesided from time to time?

Raising temperature is contraproductive now!
Breathing is not easy for your rays after the massive increase of this gill parasiste, as you can easily see on your video (or by looking into your tank). Raising the temperature lowers the oxygene level in your water and makes everything worse! Tropical gill parasites are not impressed very much by the higher temperature. I'd go to 82-84.

Salt does not solve the problem here. It can help for a short time, cause the gills will release slime, but it wont solve the problem. I would not use it here, cause it'll also affect your filter bacteria!

Using a medicine with the active ingredient Praziquantel, will solve the heavy breathing problem within a few hours and I'd bet, that they'll all eat again within only 24 hours......if they are not damaged too much from your "additional treatments" :(

You can use Tremazol, but I'd prefer Wormex out of the koi sector, it's working much better.

Tremazol has to be used 2 or better 3 times within a certain interval, depending on the individual water temperature which regulates the developement of the gill worms eggs. Eggs cannot be affected by Praziquantel and you must get the hatched worms before laying eggs again.......or you will get the same probleme a few days/weeks/months later once again. Tremazol must be removed of the tank within 8-10 hours, because of the possible massive bacteria explosion (filter bacteria) and used again after the right time, which is difficult. Wormex can be left in the tank for at least 10 DAYS and within that time, it'll kill almost all worms, cause almost all worms hatch during 10 period of time. You'll never be able to gill all rays parasites, but you can kill as much, that the ray can handle the rest of them allone. As you can now for sure read between the lines, you do not have to have brought the parasites inside the tank now, they could also have been in the P14 since years and could break out because of stress, which P14 are very impressable for......I also had this problem for a few times within the last years....always after I tried to combine them with leopoldi ;) meanwhile I've given up to try that.

There is no need to hurry, lower the temperature, dont do any nonsens like esha or salt now and try to get the right medicine. Gill worm's won't kill your rays that quick.....the most dangerous this is the keepers impatience and fear. Dont forget to remove your cabon- and polyfilter when using medicine.

btw: I am sure about what I am telling you, believe me, I am a breeder and I'd have plenty of quarantaine tanks ;)

Regards
Stefan

thanks so much for the good info

with the Wormex how do you put that in the tank as i can only find it in a table
 
Some great information in this thread, but also some lousy attitudes.
 
Madding;4223069; said:
Some great information in this thread, but also some lousy attitudes.

Just what i was thinking,good luck richard.



Steve
 
StefanW;4223162; said:
Wormex is a powder, which I am solving in alcohol (koimed disinfection).

Look here for some info www.koi-med.de there is also some information in english.

Regards
Stefan

You seem like a really nice bloke and very confident! Useful info and thanks for sharing!
 
Hi Richard,

the video confirms my first thought. Here is another vote for treatment of gill worms.
As I said we have treated over 100 rays and never lost one from the treatment.

When treating look at your rays. They will lie in the current and cough and feel relievement very fast. Within a couple of days the breathng will go back to normal. Feeding should start very soon after.

If you are not able to get wormex and should use tremazol ther are some things extra things to mention. While treating airate well and have alot of current. If the water should get cloudy before the 8 hours are over change 80% then. Stefan has explained the rest.

Wish you the best of luck.

Greetings Mark
 
hi richard. looks like some good info in the thread even if some wasnt in the politest way i think it still had good intentions .

keep us updated with the progress and good luck :)
 
forgive me for being a bit nieve but having not seen gill worms before or any related problems im having trouble seeing the bit in the video that makes it obvious that gill worms are the problem . im not saying its not the problem . just asking someone to point out what i should be looking for .

many thanks.
 
well we got to a solution in the end

i have not had any problems with any of the rays i have kept in the last 15 years with the exception on a male aggression

when things like this happen i panic and ask for advice on the one forum i thought i would get help how wrong can i be

from bad water to get a RO i was led up the garden path which is a shame

with some forum members just coming out of the wood work to attack me

but hey i can take as much as i give out unlike some other on here

thanks to Stefan and mark for the much needed help
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com