My 3 common goldfish(8"ea.) actually keep the sand in my 210 very clean as they sift the sand constantly. I have a koi in with them and its 8" also, same story. The Oscar, 15", in the same tank, makes a huge mess when eating, but very little poo. The biggest mess maker is my Royal Pleco(L190). This fish is like a chainsaw, mowing through the driftwood, dusting everything in the tank with "sawdust". It is EVERYWHERE!!!!