Guy has no idea what he's talking about...black water isn't going to help calm any fish down in a frigg'n bag - only the sedative pills folks use will do somthing like that.
I've been through things like this before - having spent thousands of dollars on fish online. Honestly - PayPal isn't going to do anything to help you, and if you ignore this you're only encouraging this guy to go rip other people off.
If you've contacted him and get no reply or a "all sales are final" quote then I'd call whichever bank/credit card you used to pay for it with through PayPal and file a dispute.
I've gotten a lot of my money back through disputes - some times I've even been able to get people black listed from PayPal as a result of digging far enough to find other folks who were ripped off by the same people.
I've been through things like this before - having spent thousands of dollars on fish online. Honestly - PayPal isn't going to do anything to help you, and if you ignore this you're only encouraging this guy to go rip other people off.
If you've contacted him and get no reply or a "all sales are final" quote then I'd call whichever bank/credit card you used to pay for it with through PayPal and file a dispute.
I've gotten a lot of my money back through disputes - some times I've even been able to get people black listed from PayPal as a result of digging far enough to find other folks who were ripped off by the same people.