florida gar and oscar

[danny2875]

Of course. My O lives perfectly with my gar. No aggression at all.

 

[JAF]

I don't really see why not, I've kept all of my previous gars with O's. They seem to get along great; though as many have said, it really depends on the temper of your oscar.

 

[xander]

 

[dvsgp6]

ive kept my gars also with my wc oscar just fine also, i dont see why not if it works out for the guy just let him do it if not then just move out a fish, i always here people saying dont put gars wtih pbass also, then i see those same people putting pbass with gars , also dont florida gars live in the wild with oscars, seen plenty of vids in florida people catching oscars and fl gars in the same spots

 

[Lepisosteus platyrhincus]

wild is different than captive. and they dont exist in the same areas(SA fish). were are these vids u claim??
AND LAST BUT NOT FREAKIN LEAST DONT PUT AN OSCAR WITH ANY KIND OF GAR!!!!!!

and out of frustration

 

[Spatula]

I have random question if I may. In that pic you posted... are those real rocks in the background or is that one of those posters you put behind the tank to make it scenic?
If they are real then how big is your tank?

 

[JAF]

wild is different than captive. and they dont exist in the same areas(SA fish). were are these vids u claim??
AND LAST BUT NOT FREAKIN LEAST DONT PUT AN OSCAR WITH ANY KIND OF GAR!!!!!!

and out of frustration

You can find vids of p-bass with gars on youtube, they seem to be alright together. Same with o's and gars for me, never had any trouble keeping them together.

 

[dvsgp6]

wild is different than captive. and they dont exist in the same areas(SA fish). were are these vids u claim??
AND LAST BUT NOT FREAKIN LEAST DONT PUT AN OSCAR WITH ANY KIND OF GAR!!!!!!

and out of frustration

first of all read my post again, not once did i mention SA, i mention FLORIDA, and your telling me since they are found in the same lakes where wild pbass are in florida dont make them wild. also i never mention captive, and THEY DO LIVE IN FLORIDA IN THE WILD WITH PBASS , BUT I GUESS FOR YOU THE WILD IS ONLY IF SA

bro also how are you gonna tell me the vids that i watch are not from florida, are you some phsychic or something ,oh and yes the vids that i do claim are from FLORIDA FISHING NOT FROM SA

 

[Lepisosteus platyrhincus]

UH u said Oscars live with florida gars in the wild. Florida gars live in Florida. Oscars live in South America.
If i may

also dont florida gars live in the wild with oscars, seen plenty of vids in florida people catching oscars and fl gars in the same spots

u didnt say p-bass u said oscars. reread ur own post before insulting me.

 

[dvsgp6]

i want you to look at these vids, shot from same person in florida also same place ok , caught a gar and a oscar, or is this captive bred since that what you were claiming i was watching
http://www.youtube.com/user/carag001#p/u/93/rohQblYi4rk

http://www.youtube.com/user/carag001#p/u/108/NTkyy4uUCl8