freshwater bamboo shark

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Personally I think, it's BS, I think the guy dumped gold fish into a marine tank and took the short film before the goldfish got too badly damaged by the salt. But there is another posibility. The aquarium could be a tank where sodium ions have been replaced by calcium ions in the form of calcium chloride with a small amount of sodium chloride. It works for many bony fishes and crusteceans but I have never seen or heard of it being used for sharks.
 
Hdeuce;1998735; said:
Not to be difficult or to disagree with you, but he actually said that it wasnt completely freshwater. He said he keeps low levels of salinity in the tank. I dont know any of the biology but maybe there is enough salt in the tank that the shark can function but not enough salt to upset the systems of the goldfish .

That is another possibility, goldfish and koi too for that matter can live in elevated salinities. That and a high calcium chloride level could be the trick, there does seem to be arragonite gravel in the tank.
 
Zoodiver;1998676; said:
There are a LOT of sharks/rays that can handle low salt levels at birth or for short periods. However, the claim of keeping this bamboo in 100% fresh is either a lie, or a short lived shark. Bamboos can't osmoregulate their body like bulls etc can. It will slowly shut down from the inside out and do irreversable damage to it.

Hdeuce;1998735; said:
Not to be difficult or to disagree with you, but he actually said that it wasnt completely freshwater. He said he keeps low levels of salinity in the tank. I dont know any of the biology but maybe there is enough salt in the tank that the shark can function but not enough salt to upset the systems of the goldfish .

First off the guy is claiming to be keeping this Bamboo - in nearly freshwater (SG 1.005 or about 7 ppt) - IIRC. So while it's not 100% freshwater - it's still technical considered to be freshwater. And there in lies the problem.

Yes - as Matt already pointed out, there are many species of sharks or rays that can enter waters of greatly reduced salinity for brief periods. But there's no known species(at least that I've ever heard of) of Carpet Shark (Orectolobiforms) is usually found in water with a SG of less than 1.0148 or 20 ppt. And that includes that Nurse Shark (Ginglymostoma cirratum) - which is known to inhabit the brackish magroove swamps, and salt marshs of Southern Florida & the Bahamas during breeding season.

So the salinity level is definitely far to low to the type of shark -he's attempting to keep. BTW - The generally accepted absolute minimum salinity level that is generally recommended for keeping a Bamboo shark or any other type of carpet shark for long term is at least 1.0178-1.020 SG or about 24-27 ppt.
 
There was an article published by Mote Marine Lab (FL) that touched slightly on the abilities of bulls to survive in freshwater.


Bull Sharks: A Real Balancing Act

By: Randolph Fillmore


Michelle Heupel has spent hundreds of hours catching, tagging, releasing and tracking young bull sharks in Southwest Florida’s Caloosahatchee River. Bull sharks, named for their muscular, buffed-up appearance, have the unique talent of being able to live in both salt and fresh water, and much of Heupel’s research is aimed at unraveling how they do it. She also wants to know how the youngest bull sharks react when salinity levels change.

“I want to know more about how bull sharks — the only shark species known to frequent freshwater environments — survive in fresh water,” said Heupel, Ph.D, a staff scientist in Mote’s Center for Shark Research. “We also want to find out if water management practices that change the natural salinity levels of the river affect how bull sharks use their habitat.”

According to Heupel, bull sharks have been known to travel 1,000 miles up the Mississippi River. How do they survive and thrive in fresh water?

“Bull sharks have a salt pump,” said Heupel. It’s not an organ or a real pump, but a cellular ability to retain salt when breathing high concentrations of fresh water. Heupel hopes to study the physiological processes going on in bull shark cells, the process that allows them to cellularly “osmoregulate” their body fluids to cope with their environment and stay for long periods in a freshwater environment. Although young bull sharks have this ability, they generally choose to stay in a moderately salty environment, somewhere in between fresh and salt water. One focus of Heupel’s research is how well young bull sharks, those less than 2 years old, tolerate fresh water.

“The big question is whether living in fresh water is more stressful for these smaller animals than for adults,” Heupel said. “It appears that the animals change their behavior to spur their growth at young ages. As salinity declines upstream, sharks head back toward the bay where salinity is higher. We assume that this is because retaining salt uses energy that could be dedicated to growth.”

Heupel catches bull sharks by longline fishing, then weighs and measures the animals. Finally, a transmitter is attached to the shark’s dorsal fin, and the animal is sent on its way. Strategically placed hydrophones that record the time, date and identity of the bull sharks that pass by track them 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Information is periodically downloaded from the monitors, and water salinity levels where the sharks roam are tested.

Early data show young bull sharks ventured farther upriver in 2004 than in 2003, a very wet year, with a lot of freshwater runoff. The young animals appeared to prefer saltwater.

“We are seeing that the young animals stay in their estuarine nurseries for a long time,” Heupel said. “The ratio of fresh to salt water seems to have a more noticeable effect on bull sharks less than 1 year old. It appears they become more tolerant of high or low salinity as they age.”

Saltwater fluctuations can be blamed on the increasing or decreasing flow of fresh water downstream and the changes in tidal pushes of salt water upstream, said Heupel. Her work is partially funded by the agency that controls fresh water released from Lake Okeechobee through the Caloosahatchee River. Agency officials want to know whether large volumes of fresh water periodically released downstream pose a danger to the young bull sharks using that habitat. “Forty-five percent of the water released from Lake Okeechobee, usually in later summer, flows down the Caloosahatchee River toward bull shark nurseries,” Heupel said.

Why should research seek answers to help understand and protect bull sharks? “They’re natural predators and without them, estuaries — and rivers feeding estuaries with fresh water — could be overrun with some species,” said Heupel.

It’s all about keeping the balance.

Dr. Michelle Heupel’s study was partially funded by the South Florida Water Management Disrict.
 
A thousand miles up the Mississippi River? Everybody Panic!:nilly::nilly::nilly:
 
I'm still looking for the study done on the populations living in isolated freshwater lakes in South America (Ven). That's even more thought provoking to me.
 
Zoodiver;2014067; said:
I'm still looking for the study done on the populations living in isolated freshwater lakes in South America (Ven). That's even more thought provoking to me.

I would love to see that as well. Shark lake! It's completely isolated and there is no way they could have gotten there even during high water seasons?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com