HELP bichir with big fish

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Oh, I see how that works. The world according to Frank, again.





That wasn't an insult, Frank. Had I stated that your comment was idiotic, or even asinine, it still wouldn't be considered an insult. The facts speak for themselves. The advice was idiotic, and was asinine. Entry level stuff, that I would think that a Silver VIP member would have learned years ago, apparently not, hence the reason that I linked to the sticky that has been on MFK for many years.

Have a nice day, and you're welcome.
Someone didnt have their ovaltine today !

I agree silver tip vip i am not. Is there a way i can remove it and move on from this ?
 
yeah im not gone release . First of all it gets to cold here in the netherlands so they will die in the winter. Second i dont destroy ecosystems, thats not responsible at all.

Good choice, even at 17 yrs of age you seem to understand the potential results of releasing aquarium fish back into the wild. :thumbsup:

Hopefully others will learn from your experience. Good luck.
 
Oh, I see how that works. The world according to Frank, again.





That wasn't an insult, Frank. Had I stated that your comment was idiotic, or even asinine, it still wouldn't be considered an insult. The facts speak for themselves. The advice was idiotic, and was asinine. Entry level stuff, that I would think that a Silver VIP member would have learned years ago, apparently not, hence the reason that I linked to the sticky that has been on MFK for many years.

Have a nice day, and you're welcome.
Nope I still stand with what I said as longs fish is native to where your releasing it i dont see the problem the chances of the fish catching a disease from the tank and then spread is not very likely to happen. Also its a catfish which can survive on its own since its a scavenger.
 
Good for you, Anthony. The reality is that aquarium fish can introduce exotic parasites and diseases, which is why many jurisdiction's prohibit, or at the very least, advise against such activity. Not very likely to happen doesn't pass the sniff test, when native waterways along with the fish, flora & fauna are placed at risk. This is also why dead fish should also never be flushed down the toilet. Common sense really, apparently even for a 17 yr old kid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matteus
Good for you, Anthony. The reality is that aquarium fish can introduce exotic parasites and diseases, which is why many jurisdiction's prohibit, or at the very least, advise against such activity. Not very likely to happen doesn't pass the sniff test, when native waterways along with the fish, flora & fauna are placed at risk. This is also why dead fish should also never be flushed down the toilet. Common sense really, apparently even for a 17 yr old kid.
Im not saying to dump exotic fish if its native and came from the water it shouldn't be a problem. I see ur point but its a slim chance of tht happening Ive never even heard of a native fish being brought into a tank then being released back where it was from and then a disease spreading to all the other wild life.
 
Anyone familiar with VHS?


It started decades ago with salmon in the Northwest, and now is found in numerous species in the Great Lakes. It has been speculated that part of the spread of this viral disease has been caused by baitfish taken from the Great Lakes area, used as breeding stock in captivity, then later released elsewhere.

From the link above; "Fish belonging to a large number of cyprinid and other species are collected from the Great Lakes and used as bait for sport fisheries around the U.S. Baitfish from Canada are routinely exported to the U.S. Additionally, some aquaculture producers collect baitfish broodstock from the Great Lakes to produce commercial baitfish in aquaculture facilities. The destinations and numbers of baitfish moved are not well documented, and regulation of this sector is inconsistent among States, or lacking entirely."

Native fish, going back to nature, can sometimes have serious consequences.


Outbreaks of infectious disease can occur when a pathogen is transferred to a new geographical area where it comes into contact with native fish which have no resistance to it. Seeing as there is no way for a hobbyist to state that their native fish is "pathogen free", after being exposed to captive conditions, it only makes good sense to never re-release a native fish back into the wild. There's no telling what it was packing when it arrived in your tank, and there's no real way in telling what it may be packing when it leaves your tank.

Hopefully we're all good on that now.
 
Anyone familiar with VHS?


It started decades ago with salmon in the Northwest, and now is found in numerous species in the Great Lakes. It has been speculated that part of the spread of this viral disease has been caused by baitfish taken from the Great Lakes area, used as breeding stock in captivity, then later released elsewhere.

From the link above; "Fish belonging to a large number of cyprinid and other species are collected from the Great Lakes and used as bait for sport fisheries around the U.S. Baitfish from Canada are routinely exported to the U.S. Additionally, some aquaculture producers collect baitfish broodstock from the Great Lakes to produce commercial baitfish in aquaculture facilities. The destinations and numbers of baitfish moved are not well documented, and regulation of this sector is inconsistent among States, or lacking entirely."

Native fish, going back to nature, can sometimes have serious consequences.


Outbreaks of infectious disease can occur when a pathogen is transferred to a new geographical area where it comes into contact with native fish which have no resistance to it. Seeing as there is no way for a hobbyist to state that their native fish is "pathogen free", after being exposed to captive conditions, it only makes good sense to never re-release a native fish back into the wild. There's no telling what it was packing when it arrived in your tank, and there's no real way in telling what it may be packing when it leaves your tank.

Hopefully we're all good on that now.
Yah were good I understand what ur saying.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com