Help with newly introduced Motoro stingray. !!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I dont think its 2.0 out of tap. That was after he found it dead in the system.
 
I just got home and the ray is doing worse, her entire disk corners are flaking and white as if the ammonia burn is eating her flesh . I did a very good test on everything just now and here are my readings, please help me out on this :

PS : She actually died, when i turn the lights on i realize that she was no longer breathing. Took her out and took some pictures of the poor thing. I can only blame myself for the disaster and hopefully this is a lesson for everyone who wants to get a freshwater ray. Just because you love the look of the fish and want it in your tank, please make sure you understand what you're buying and the requirements this beautiful fish needs. Not even about the money wasted, just kind of upsetting letting such a gorgeous creature die like that , and all my fault. Still need help with my water please, would hate to lose any more.

Water in tank Readings : PH - 6.0 , Ammonia - 2.0 , Nitrate - 0 , Nitrite - 0
Tap Water Readings : PH - 7.0 , Ammonia - 2.0 , Nitrate - 0.5 , Nitrite , 0
55 G brute 24hr Aged Water ( No chemicals added ) : PH - 7.0 - Ammonia - 0.5 , Nitrate - 0 , Nitrite - 0

I would do a huge water change but i only have 55 Gallons to refill it with, the rest would be straight from tap water... don't want to do that. Seems like the 55 G water changes ive been doing twice a week doesn't affect the high ammonia, just blends in with it. Help asap plz, Ty

I hope do you do get another one since they are illegal in Florida.
 
2.0 ammonia is a big issue and even worse coming out of the tap- i would call your water company

Not sure if they would do anything about it, i could give it a try i guess but 2.0 right out of tap water makes it very hard for me to treat the water before it goes in the tank. cause even if i treat it. I dont know if its good enough to not leave any or low trace of ammonia behind. :/
 
Not sure if they would do anything about it, i could give it a try i guess but 2.0 right out of tap water makes it very hard for me to treat the water before it goes in the tank. cause even if i treat it. I dont know if its good enough to not leave any or low trace of ammonia behind. :/
there is no way to "treat" for ammonia
 
But that 2.0 was the tank water after the ray had been dead in it for how long? What is your actual ammonia readings straight out of tap. If it is 2.0 you have issues but if it was that high then your other fish would show some type of distress.

If its trace then setup a drip. I still would lean towards lack of filtration/bio media.
Either way I would call to find out why there is any ammonia in your water supply.

You can only dilute ammonia until bio breaks it down or detoxify ammonia.
 
But that 2.0 was the tank water after the ray had been dead in it for how long? What is your actual ammonia readings straight out of tap. If it is 2.0 you have issues but if it was that high then your other fish would show some type of distress.

If its trace then setup a drip. I still would lean towards lack of filtration/bio media.
Either way I would call to find out why there is any ammonia in your water supply.

The 2.0 Ammonia its the water and and its also the reading of the water coming straight from the tap. I have no idea why my other fish don't care for the high ammonia, the rest of my stock has grown into the tank so maybe the adapted to the high ammonia in water? not sure but everyone else eats just fine and are showing no irregular signs. My bio filtration is pretty decent. an eheim 2262 packed with Biohome / Eheim Substrate Pro / Porus ceramic rings / and 1 gallon of Seachem matrix. no mechanical filtration in it , all bio.
 
2.0 out of tap is extremely high. I would definitley call water supply. Meanwhile take a sample of your tap water to a lfs or pool place and have them test it just to confirm your results. Or even take it someplace else with more credibility like a water testing facility if need be. Never heard of 2.0 out of tap.

I would not introduce any new rays in there until you get it figured out.
 
2.0 out of tap is extremely high. I would definitley call water supply. Meanwhile take a sample of your tap water to a lfs or pool place and have them test it just to confirm your results. Or even take it someplace else with more credibility like a water testing facility if need be. Never heard of 2.0 out of tap.

I would not introduce any new rays in there until you get it figured out.

going to do a quick test again and ill post pictures of the results. Also is there any reason why my tank water has a PH reading of 6.0 and my tap water is 7.0 which is ideal? and what are the benefits or downside of having low PH ( 6.0 ). I don't think ill be getting a new ray anytime soon, until i see or figure out a way how to get rid of the huge ammonia coming out of my tap water. Even thinking in installing a system for my tap water. Here are some shots on how badly she was being burnt by ammonia, really gets too you when an animal so beautiful dies due to our mistakes . Also posting a pic of my tap water ammonia reading. 2.0 again.. might seem 1.0 in pic due to light hitting right on the test tube.

fsdfdsf.jpg

fvbbv.jpg

gvsd.jpg

unnamed.jpg
 
takes away ammonia without any chemicals added. That's the whole purpose of aging water . ;/
I would check with your local municipality to see if they treated with additional ammonia?
The answer to dealing with chlorine, ammonia and chloramine is to use Prime/SAFE or an equivalent product. Allowing water to age before adding it to tank will allow pH to stabilize. In addition, agingwater can off gas chlorine but not chloramine.
Prime and other water conditioners bind ammonia. Then ammonia is slowly released and metabolizied into nitirite and on to nitrate. Some test kits will measure total ammonia (both free and bound). Bound ammonia is not toxic as it is bound.
If nitrate in tank is very high (40 ppm or higher), it maybe that nitrogen cycle is running in reverse. This is not likely but it is possible.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com