DB, i would understand better if this was the exporters fault but it is not, so your arguement holds no ground, unless someone can prove otherwise... the rays were listed forsale on 1-9-12 which were already in shawns posession. i can tell by the blue tarps that his ponds are made out of. IMO the rays look decently healthy in the pics from 1-9-12 too. it is now over a month later when these rays were shipped out... my conclusion is they have been neglected while in shawns posession