My single biggest reason to avoid the big chains is the fact that if I buy their fish and successfully spawn them they will not take the babies in sale or trade. Same goes for plants. How they treat the livestock is a mute point to me.
I can’t even take Petco
- Thread starter The Morning
- Start date
The only lfs i remember not selling sick fish was absolutely fish. As much as i loved shark AQ the conditions were nothing to write home about. I once purchased a few argentea knowing they had IP
I am not used to seeing fish in this condition other than petco. The LFS I used to go to had around 100 tanks and over the ten plus years I went there I can’t recall ever seeing ich. And even a dead fish was a rare occasion. As I said every time I go into this store I check to see what they have and always find struggling fish, sick or dead. That being said this is the first time I have seen ich to that degree. Makes me question the quality of their suppliers.
Hello: How is this the fault of the fish store? Before I buy from a shop I go around to all the tanks. If I see ick or dead fish I talk to the clerks. Many times I do not buy from some stores at all. If the clerks give decent information I may buy from healthy tanks. By decent I mean they are aware of the issues and have taken steps to deal with it.
Even the better shops I go to sometimes have dead fish. Not always a sign of bad practice.
I buy from them from time to time and have had very good luck. I also QT all new fish. If I did not QT and infected my other fish that is on me. I find no particular issues with Petco that are not sometimes found in most shops.
totally possible that your Petco is not a good one. Just pointing out that a store having some fish with ich, does not make the store a bad one, and from your original post alone, It seems like they did the right thing. Likely scenario is they got a bunch of fish in (they get them every week) and some had ich, so they had to isolate all those tanks. The hole in the grand design is that the ich could likely have spread to the whole system before they saw it; though that's true of any fish store that has many fish on a large system.
I also worked at absolutely fish for a couple years, they are still open and doing well. Their FW tanks were mostly all enclosed individual systems, which I think is better than having large systems in stores. Even at AF they get fish in with ich, and they put a little paper sign up that the fish aren't for sale as well. I'd recommend checking it out if your in the area, real nice store. Which is probably why they are outlasting so many other LFS's in Jersey.
I also worked at absolutely fish for a couple years, they are still open and doing well. Their FW tanks were mostly all enclosed individual systems, which I think is better than having large systems in stores. Even at AF they get fish in with ich, and they put a little paper sign up that the fish aren't for sale as well. I'd recommend checking it out if your in the area, real nice store. Which is probably why they are outlasting so many other LFS's in Jersey.
Hello; I go to two different Petco stores in cities about 80 miles apart. Both have had good tanks and I have bought from both with good results.
I also stop most times when out and about at a Hardies. Most are good clean stores. There is only one I no longer will stop at because of a nasty restroom. But that may have been just a bad day.
So yeah he may have a bad shop but I have seen this dump on big chain stores before. I have not personally been to a bad one myself.
I agree with everything that was stated but like to add that it also depends on the Manager's and employees knowledge and skill set. Also always high turnover rate and the same store will show it.
Last edited:
Yeah havent been there in a while. Tanks are clean, good employees too. But way over priced. They dont cary anything close to what shark had tho. Not worth the drive for you unless your in the area. You should definitely check out monster if your ever in nyc.
I agree. Most of the petco's and petsmarts ive been in had spotless tanks. Complaining about these stores is just the poplar thaaang to do.
