I.D. if you dare....

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Before you're so quick to call it a scam, you should be sure that it was a malicious scam. I didn't purchase any of these, but I don't think it's fair to call it a scam. The seller seems to be genuine in his belief of what they are. As far as whether or not they're indos or ST, I dunno. I compared them to my old STs, and I couldn't make aa positive ID so I stayed away. But, there are some pretty legit experts who have weighed in with ST. I don't think anyone wants to speak up publicly unless they're bashing the seller... Kinda sad.
 
WBs are almost always pretty stable. Those dats look blotchy. Indo takes my vote.
 
Clay;4506911; said:
Before you're so quick to call it a scam, you should be sure that it was a malicious scam. I didn't purchase any of these, but I don't think it's fair to call it a scam. The seller seems to be genuine in his belief of what they are. As far as whether or not they're indos or ST, I dunno. I compared them to my old STs, and I couldn't make aa positive ID so I stayed away. But, there are some pretty legit experts who have weighed in with ST. I don't think anyone wants to speak up publicly unless they're bashing the seller... Kinda sad.

I understand what u are saying, but these nice looking ITs have been attempted To pass as baby ST for many months now.
To me it's quite simple. Wrong price.

A Scam is a scam. Malicious or not.
 
Clay;4506911; said:
Before you're so quick to call it a scam, you should be sure that it was a malicious scam. I didn't purchase any of these, but I don't think it's fair to call it a scam. The seller seems to be genuine in his belief of what they are. As far as whether or not they're indos or ST, I dunno. I compared them to my old STs, and I couldn't make aa positive ID so I stayed away. But, there are some pretty legit experts who have weighed in with ST. I don't think anyone wants to speak up publicly unless they're bashing the seller... Kinda sad.
Some of us tried, but he's so defensive, and hostile, so we just leave him alone! :D
 
Clay;4506911; said:
Before you're so quick to call it a scam, you should be sure that it was a malicious scam. I didn't purchase any of these, but I don't think it's fair to call it a scam. The seller seems to be genuine in his belief of what they are. As far as whether or not they're indos or ST, I dunno. I compared them to my old STs, and I couldn't make aa positive ID so I stayed away. But, there are some pretty legit experts who have weighed in with ST. I don't think anyone wants to speak up publicly unless they're bashing the seller... Kinda sad.

Only you mentioned the seller mate.
If you bought one for the price stated only to take it home and in 6 months find out that you'd paid the price quote for an IT what would you call it? An honest mistake and put it down to experience?
IMHO it doesn't matter who is doing the scamming, if they're 3 bar indos being sold as ST it is a scam.
 
jlnguyen74;4507354; said:
Some of us tried, but he's so defensive, and hostile, so we just leave him alone! :D
Is that aimed at me or Ade?
 
classic-chassis;4508717; said:
Is that aimed at me or Ade?
I think it is a pretty accurate description of the seller of these "baby ST's".
 
K
 
classic-chassis;4510151; said:
...and I bet he did'nt sell them all,rather,he found out just what they were and decided to no longer list them in order to save face.
 
LOL, so he was scammed. Sad really.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com