ID these bluegill please

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
what about this one.. i posted a thread but didnt get too many replies.

DSC02359.jpg


DSC02365.jpg
 
why does the fish in the first pic have a taller body and lighter coloration than the fish in the 4th and 5th pics?
 
Fishyfan;523227; said:
why does the fish in the first pic have a taller body and lighter coloration than the fish in the 4th and 5th pics?


Looks like the difference is age. Older sunfish tend to get taller rather than longer. Color changes quite abit with age as well.

Looks like bluegill and the last is an interesting looking longear. Our look different around here.

Yellow sunfish... bluegill and yellow sunfish to make a Green sunfish... You need a comedy routine Skipjack:ROFL:
 
Fishyfan;522484; said:
I think i have 2 different kinds:


one of my dads friends brought these over for me. i asked if he could catch me some baby bluegill but when he went fishing he could only catch these big ones. i think im going to return them because they are a little bit too big...just wondering what kind they are?

I hate to be the one to say this but it is a BAD idea to release these fish back to the wild.

1.) it may be illegal, check your state regulations, in many states it is illegal to move captive fish from one water shed to another with out a permit

2.) you could introduce a disease into a local fish population, even a privately owned pond and kill thousands of fish!!

you have 3 real options here:

1.) try and give them away, post on this and other web sights, someone out there may be chomping at the bit for one of these fish.

2.) Keep the fish and enjoy! a full grown bluegill is spectacular (these are not full grown by a long shot, they look to be 6"-8" long, they get to 12" or larger), in a very short time they will eat pellet food (you should give them worms, crickets, and other frozen foods about once a week or so) in about 6 weeks or so they will be rushing to the front glass begging for food. I think you may have 4 fish here? I could be wrong but i think that they would be OK in a 100 gal set up or you could pair them off in 55 gal or 75 gal set ups, according to your profile you have a 180 gal tank, that would work great for 4 bluegill in 6 months those fish would look incredible.
(please note: this could be the longest run on sentence in forum history, i like to use comas, see i did it again,)

3.) your third choice is too euthanize them, it sucks but most of us have had to do it. place them in a zip-lock bag and put them in the freezer. fish are cold blooded and their metabolism will just shut down after the temp drops below a certain degree

(steps down off of his soap box, watches as it float away)
 
hmt321;523416; said:
I hate to be the one to say this but it is a BAD idea to release these fish back to the wild.

1.) it may be illegal, check your state regulations, in many states it is illegal to move captive fish from one water shed to another with out a permit

2.) you could introduce a disease into a local fish population, even a privately owned pond and kill thousands of fish!!

How would i introduce a disease into the local fish population? the water is from the lake, they havent been exposed to any of my other fish, and they will be going into the same lake they came from. Ive only had them a few days.
 
Fishyfan;523444; said:
How would i introduce a disease into the local fish population? the water is from the lake, they havent been exposed to any of my other fish, and they will be going into the same lake they came from. Ive only had them a few days.

In all honesty, after a few days there is probably no harm. But:

It is illegal to release captive fish in almost every state.

If you kill these fish instead of releasing them, it will not have any effect on the fish population.

You risk no exotic diseases being introduced by not releasing them.

When you put a fish in a tank, you have a responsibility to keep it for it's life, or until you end it's life.

Your fish PROBABLY pose no threat, but in the future do not keep fish you can't or won't care for.
 
awesome. Aren't longears illegal to keep since they are endangered??

And if you don't want your gillies, I'll be happy to take em :P
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com