I'm still tempted to get a catfish

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Moloch I think you pretty much have the right Idea. But on the pictus I would have to disagree on what alot of peopel say at keeping these guys in schools.. when they are juvies they like schools.. when adults they don't really enjoy eachothers company unless you have a pair, and even then some aggression can occur. I doubt removing the Cons would increase your JDs aggression to a level it would impact the tanks balances. He'll be happy to harass the tiger barbs ( imo good choice on a dither for him/her and yours Sens.) I'de personally feel confortable with your stock dropping the cons and getting a pictus. Long term you know you'll need to upgrade for the Sens, at their size 1 yr sounds about right. Pictus generally will hit 4"-6" fairly fast then slow down. Long as you keep up with water changes and your tank ( which seems like your more then willing to do) I seriously doubt you'de have any issues with the stock list. Btw when your looking to upgrade look into a 120Wide 4'x2'x2'(? i think thats the height I could be wrong.. I'm a footprint person..) The extra depth to the tank will go a long way. They also usually cost about the same as a 125.

I have 2 sens, a tt eel, whiptail cat, and a dwarf pike cichlid in a 40breeder atm. The sens and TT will be getting an upgrade eventually. But my tanks perameters are always good. I'm religious on my upkeep. As long as you understand the adult needs of your fish growing them out is rarely an issue in smaller tanks. Its when you stuff fish in tanks to small for adults and do not Care for them properly aka Lots of water changes, and filtration. that people run into issues.

And you can never have to much filtration.. ever.. Just to much water circulation for some species.

Ultimately sounds like no matter what you decide you know enough to make good choices.
 
Thanks man that good info. Definitely makes me want to consider pictus cats a little heavier. It sounds about the same as some peoples logic on abk's...need schools when they're young for confidence and whatnot but will eventually kill each other.

And yes I'm looking for footprint first, Im gunning for a 5 foot tank (125-180). I'll take a 125, if I can get a bit more I'll go 150 for the extra height and if I can go one step more 180 for the extra width.

I dunno, we'll see. I'm riding in the car listening to my wife ramble about something right now though...prime time to convince her stock changes;)
 
IMO/IME a 36" tank is good for one Senegal only for two I'd say get a 75gal. Also they'll reach between 8"-12" in the next 6 months and you'll need an upgrade fast. I wouldn't get another catfish until you have at least a 4'x18" footprint on hand.

Also CA/SA cichlids usually dont do well in the long run with Polys.

PS: don't listen to LBF many people even admins have recommended him to get a larger tank...
 
Darth Scohin;4571468; said:
IMO/IME a 36" tank is good for one Senegal only for two I'd say get a 75gal. Also they'll reach between 8"-12" in the next 6 months and you'll need an upgrade fast. I wouldn't get another catfish until you have at least a 4'x18" footprint on hand.

Also CA/SA cichlids usually dont do well in the long run with Polys.

PS: don't listen to LBF many people even admins have recommended him to get a larger tank...

Yeah I've been reading a few of his threads here & there I know to ignore him, but if he comes in my thread saying **** I'll give him a piece of my mind;)

I think the 2 sen's will be fine for at least a year in the 65 if I did my research right. I'm expecting them to get closer to the 8-10" range (unless, like I said, I have unusually larg specimens). I'm not planning on keeping them there for life, but they'll be fine for a good while. If they dont get along with the cichlids even in a larger tank then I'll probably leave the jack and cons in the 65 and move on from there.
 
Darth Scohin;4571468; said:
IMO/IME a 36" tank is good for one Senegal only for two I'd say get a 75gal. Also they'll reach between 8"-12" in the next 6 months and you'll need an upgrade fast. I wouldn't get another catfish until you have at least a 4'x18" footprint on hand.

Also CA/SA cichlids usually dont do well in the long run with Polys.

PS: don't listen to LBF many people even admins have recommended him to get a larger tank...
ok name me 2 threads that someone said get a BIGGER tank!! they all have told me to FILL my tank the rest of the way NOT get a bigger tank..... name me TWO threads ( better yet post them or PM them to me )...... i DONT need a bigger tank, my tank is big enough to handle whats in there, its the tank thats half full that is causing everyone to tell me to finish filling it...
 
Dude...go away.
 
fishbum;4571586; said:
I would not suggest getting a catfish for your tank.

Based on .. ?

livebearerfreak;4571735; said:
thank you someone agrees...

A random internet opinion with no supporting argument is hardly a steady platform to stand on.

fishbum;4571586; said:
Ultimately sounds like no matter what you decide you know enough to make good choices.

That, I would agree with. :)
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com